Although the incident has gone down in history as being quite farcical, it was met with strong condemnation at the time. Government ministers from both the United Kingdom and Ireland condemned it. The leaders of the
Alliance Party and the
Social Democratic and Labour Party also condemned it.
Ken Maginnis of the
Ulster Unionist Party was also critical of the loyalists involved. Peter Robinson and the DUP justified the incursion by saying that it was done to highlight the lack of cross-border security, despite reform in this area being promised under the Agreement. They claimed that the takeover of Clontibret proved that no real reforms had taken place, and was thus a propaganda victory for opponents of the Agreement. Peter Robinson was charged under the
Offences Against the State Act. He was granted bail and appeared in court in
Dundalk in August. He pleaded guilty to unlawful assembly, and was fined
IR£17,500. The alternative was a prison sentence, which would have resulted in Robinson losing his Westminster seat. He was forced to give up deputy leadership of the DUP but he was later reinstated. The court hearing triggered '
Belfast-style rioting' in
Dundalk between local
republicans and police. Cars belonging to Robinson's supporters were damaged and petrol bombs were thrown. Robinson's supporters had had any items that could be construed as offensive weapons taken from them by the Gardaí when they crossed the border into the Republic. Robinson and DUP leader
Ian Paisley made a formal complaint about the 'totally inadequate protection' they were given during the hearing. This renewed speculation that Robinson had really sought to increase his standing within the DUP, and become leader. Robinson rejected Paisley's account as a 'failure of recollection'. He claimed that Paisley was initially meant to go and that Robinson only stood in for him after Paisley had to go to a funeral in the United States. DUP sources speaking to the
Belfast Telegraph backed Robinson's account, saying that Paisley was among the organisers. Robinson had in fact succeeded Paisley as leader of the DUP, a position he held from 2008-2015. ==References==