The review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes assigned
Close Your eyes an approval rating of 46%, based on 37 reviews assessed as positive or negative; the average rating among the reviews is 5.7/10. Jessica Winter, writing for
The Village Voice, said of
Close Your Eyes, "Willing's confused procedural—derived from a novel by Madison Smartt Bell—is a hasty throwback to the sado-medieval
Exorcist descendants of the turn of the millennium (
Stigmata,
Stir of Echoes,
Lost Souls). The somnolent cast can't keep the faith."
Peoples staff reviewed the film, writing, "
Close Your Eyes is an intelligently crafted, psychologically complex thriller in which suspense keeps building. The hypnotist has secrets of his own that are only slowly revealed. It is an indication of this movie's concern for its characters rather than bloody special effects that it spends as much time delving into the hypnotist’s sometimes tense relationship with his pregnant wife (Otto) as it does having him hunt for the killer. Visnjic... effectively dips into the same dark pool of self-loathing and depression here." Mark Jenkins, reviewing
Close Your Eyes for
The Washington Post, described the film: "Effectively foreboding and rather silly, director Nick Willing's creep-out has a British accent but a Hollywood soul." Jenkins concluded, "Shot mostly in lesser-known neighborhoods,
Close Your Eyes presents a London that many American moviegoers will not have seen before. But the plot, loosely derived from Madison Smartt Bell's 'Doctor Sleep,' is utterly stale." Stephen Holden of
The New York Times called
Close Your Eyes "a flashy, mildly tingly British thriller... adapted from Madison Smartt Bell's novel 'Doctor Sleep'". Holden said, "As the movie clanks along, relying on montages that reshuffle the same enigmatic images over and over, the fragments don't add up to a coherent jigsaw puzzle. The film is so desperate to sustain a creepy atmosphere that it throws in false jolts of horror and sudden, ominous changes of mood just to bolster a sense of mounting, insomniac paranoia."
Slant Magazines Joe McGovern said, "Shirley Henderson and Goran Visnjic sex up
Close Your Eyes—an achievement worth noting given the otherwise neutered condition of this leaden procedural, and the fact that the two actors virtually never touch." McGovern said, "The references to
Hitchcock,
Polanski, and
Nicolas Roeg are bandied about, but the movie adulterates the tight atmosphere of those filmmakers with vacant, modernist gore... Still, like most UK horror cinema,
Close Your Eyes is braced by its supporting roster of Brit pros." Stephen Dalton, writing for
The Times, said
Close Your Eyes combines "elements of
Rosemary’s Baby with some nightmarish twists" and that Willing's film "is saddled with an implausible plot". Dalton concluded, "But it is still an unnerving horror yarn that features a high-class cast, including Shirley Henderson, Paddy Considine and Corin Redgrave." ==References==