1834 Universalist Church The westernmost of the three buildings in the district, the church is a three-story
Federal style building with a
gabled roof,
quoined at the corners and topped by a square wooden tower with corner
pilasters, and wooden front
pediment. The front cobblestones are more finely graded than those on the sides, with some tooling evident in the
interstitial mortar. A stone
terrace in front is floored in brick capped with
sandstone coping. Brick also frames a
marble tablet over the front door that reads: "Erected by the First Universalist Society A D 1834 GOD IS LOVE". On the inside the lobby has stairs to the gallery, with delicate square
newels topped by spherical
finials, on each side. At the rear of the church is a platform with a
walnut pulpit and three matching
Gothic Revival pulpit chairs in front of a ''
trompe-l'œil'' painting of an alcove.
Italianate detailing is evident in the pillars and
balustrade of the
choir loft. The woodwork has been meticulously
grained by the same local painter who did the rear wall painting.
Ward House Believed to have been built around 1840 as a parsonage, it is a
hipped-roofed Federal style one-story building with a raised basement giving the effect of a ground floor. The main block is sided in cobblestone applied more carefully than that on the church. On the east and west sides of the ground level the field cobbles are set in the Gaines Pattern, in which each is part of a small hexagonal box. Quoins of
Medina sandstone mark the corners. On the northwest the house has a small frame wing, sided in vertical
tongue and groove, added later, with a porch on the west side. Its roof is supported with a
Colonial Revival fluted column. The addition itself has a shed roof. An
Italianate door with two original
stained glass windows leads into a first floor with Federal door and window casings on long, narrow Greek Revival doors. The walls are plastered directly onto the masonry. Furniture and decor reflect the 1880s.
District 5 School A half-mile (1 km) east of the other two buildings, the District 5 School is the youngest, built in 1849. It is a one-and-a-half-story Greek Revival
gabled building topped by an open
belfry with
louvered vents and domed roof at the south (front) end. Its predominately lake-washed brown cobblestones are different from the other two buildings in that they are a decorative
veneer on a wood-frame structure. Only one other cobblestone building in New York, another residence in Gaines, is known to use cobblestone this way. At the northwest corner some brick was used when repairs were necessary. The cobblestones are arranged tightly, four rows per corner quoin on the front and sides and three in the rear. A sandstone
water table runs around the building at floor level, above the fieldstone
foundation. At the roofline is a wide wooden
molded frieze with returns. The windows have plain stone trim. In the front center are two separate doors, for boys and girls, similarly treated, with small stone steps. Above them is a marble tablet reading "School District No 5 of Gaines A D 1849 Wm. J. Babbitt Esq. gratuitously superintended the erection of the building and made the district a present of the bell". It is topped with an unusual attic gable-field window. Inside, the recessed-paneled wooden doors open into separate cloakrooms 10 feet (3.3 m) square. Both have horizontal tongue-and-groove
wainscoting and plaster upper walls. The ceilings, like all in the school, are tongue-and-groove random-width plank. The boys' cloakroom has the cellar door, and a rope to ring the bell. In the classroom, the maple flooring is inclined so students in the northern portion, the rear, were sitting higher than those in the front. Its walls have a similar treatment to the cloakrooms. Original blackboards are still in place, supplemented by slate boards added to the side walls later. Behind the teacher's desk is a
cupboard and niche for a clock. The heating system of two trapdoors to the ceiling operated by a rope remains as well. ==Preservation==