Cocky received mixed reviews from critics, earning a 57 out of 100 rating on
Metacritic.
Stephen Thomas Erlewine, writing for
AllMusic, gave the album four out of five stars, writing, "unpretentious, blue-collar hard rock hasn't sounded this good in nearly 20 years, and that's reason enough to celebrate."
Entertainment Weekly writer Rob Brunner gave the album a B, writing, "Kid Rock's tear-down-the-walls ideal of a world where rappers can sip whiskey with rednecks is a compelling fiction, and if the cross-pollinated musical results aren't always as exciting as the conversation no doubt would be, you have to at least admire the breadth of his vision." Brunner felt that "Too much of
Cocky meanders into boring stylistic experiments", calling "Picture" a "sappy duet".
Rolling Stone writer Barry Walters gave
Cocky three out of five stars, writing, "Rock self-consciously builds on his badass-hick-with-a-heart-of-gold image [...] [The execution] is really corn, [...] Rock's
AC/DC,
Run-D.M.C. and
Lynyrd Skynyrd. tributes now come across as clunky imitation." ==Track listing==