In its original airing on the Fox Network during November
sweeps, the episode had a 14.4
Nielsen rating and was viewed in approximately 13.26 million homes. It finished the week ranked 29th, up from the season's average rank of 32nd. It finished second in its timeslot behind
The Cosby Show, which finished 17th with a 15.9 rating. It was the highest rated show on Fox that week. The authors of the book ''I Can't Believe It's a Bigger and Better Updated Unofficial Simpsons Guide'',
Gary Russell and
Gareth Roberts, called it "Possibly the best Simpsons episode, with a constant stream of gags, inspired animation (in particular the sequence when Homer begins to see and hear Moe everywhere, from Maggie's gurgles to the leaves on the trees), and a superb plot that twists about in every direction but the one you might expect." Nate Meyers of Digitally Obsessed gave the episode 5/5, calling it "another great chapter in the history of The Simpsons, with tons of laughs throughout". Emily VanDerWerff of
Slant Magazine called it "a very funny episode" and highlighted the plot's focus on Moe as "an example of the show gradually expanding its supporting townspeople into characters in their own right," as "Moe was just an angry bartender before this episode. After this one, he's the sad man who sometimes tastes success but always lets it slip away because of his inability to do the right thing until it's too late." VanDerWerff also interpreted the episode as a metaphor for Simon's relationship with fellow
Simpsons developers Groening and
James L. Brooks and Simon's belief that he was not receiving enough credit for
The Simpsons. Niel Harvey of
The Roanoke Times called "Flaming Moe's" a "classic bit of Simpsonia". The episode is on many lists of best
Simpsons episodes. In 2006,
IGN named "Flaming Moe's" the best episode of the third season. They wrote, "This episode has tons of standout moments, from the appearance by Aerosmith (the first time a musical act of that caliber appeared as themselves on the series); a funny payoff for all Bart's prank calls to Moe's, when a man named Hugh Jass actually does turn out to be a customer; a deftly done Cheers parody at the height of Moe's success; and Homer turning into a Phantom of the Opera type lunatic." In
Entertainment Weekly's 2003 list of the top 25
The Simpsons episodes ever, it was placed sixteenth. In 2003, Rich Weir of
AskMen.com placed the episode in second on his list of his ten favorite episodes of the show. He wrote, "As one of the early episodes that helped solidify the show's sharp wit and satirical ability, "Flaming Moe's" has everything a classic Simpsons episode should have: gut-busting humor, nifty parody, and some superstar cameos to seal the deal. [...] highlights include a performance by Aerosmith (in a guest-starring role), Bart's actually apologizing to Moe for one of his infamous prank calls, and a memorable spoof of Cheers' theme song."
AOL placed the episode sixth on their list of the top 25
Simpsons episodes.
Screen Rant called it the best episode of the third season. The episode is also a favorite of crew members. In 2003, executive producer
Al Jean listed the episode as one of his favorites. When
The Simpsons began streaming on
Disney+ in 2019, former
Simpsons writer and executive producer
Bill Oakley named this one of the best classic Simpsons episodes to watch on the service. In 2006, the members of Aerosmith were collectively named the 24th best
Simpsons guest stars by
IGN. The song "Flaming Moe's", which parodies "Where Everybody Knows Your Name" from
Cheers, was well received. Ken Tucker of
Entertainment Weekly named the song the "Best Theme Song Parody" of 1991. It was later included in the 1997 album
Songs in the Key of Springfield, a compilation of songs from the first seven seasons of the show. ==Universal Studios==