Box office With a running time of 135 minutes,
In Cold Blood premiered in the United States on December14, 1967,
Roger Ebert gave the film 4 out of 4 stars, writing, "At times one feels this is not a movie but a documentary where the events are taking place now."
Charles Champlin of
The Los Angeles Times put it on his list of the ten best films of 1967, calling it "an honest, sobering, revealing motion picture, earnest and authentic, with only minor lapses into theatricality. As the killers, Scott Wilson and Robert Blake were compellingly convincing."
Variety called it "a probing, sensitive, tasteful, balanced and suspenseful documentary-drama".
Brendan Gill of
The New Yorker wrote that "the note sounded throughout is not that of Hollywood but of a scrupulous documentary. This documentary effect is greatly enhanced by the two young men who play the murderers—Robert Blake as Perry Smith and Scott Wilson as Dick Hickock. Each in his own way is superbly mindless and menacing."
The Monthly Film Bulletin was less positive, writing that "since Brooks places his emphasis so exclusively on the killers, omitting the spectacle of the actual murders while lingering censoriously over the hangings, one fails to appreciate the real irony—the total arbitrariness—of the Clutters' deaths: they are too crudely delineated to inspire much sympathy, and in consequence the sympathy Brooks generates for the killers seems unbalanced and misplaced". On
Rotten Tomatoes,
In Cold Blood holds a rating of 76% from 46 reviews with an average rating of 8.2/10. The site's consensus reads: "
In Cold Blood is a classic docudrama with a fictional thriller's grip -- and a pair of terrific lead performances from Robert Blake and Scott Wilson".
In Cold Blood has been noted as an example of Hollywood
new realism by critics such as Chris Fujiwara. Capote biographer
Tison Pugh characterizes the film as an exercise in a "relentless pursuit of authenticity", and adds: "By putting his characters in the actual settings of their real-life counterparts, Brooks imbued his film with a reality both mundane and unbearable." Scholar
Joel Black considers the film and its representation of real-life violent incidents "a form of psychological or social documentary".
Capote's response Truman Capote was very satisfied with the film. He entrusted Richard Brooks with the adaptation because Brooks "was the only director who agreed with—and was willing to risk—my own concept of how the book should be transferred to film." When Capote visited the film's set, he met Robert Blake and Scott Wilson, who were playing the killers he had known very well, for the first time. Capote was so shaken by their resemblance to the real men that he "felt extremely uneasy in their presence" and returned to his hotel and drank an entire pint of
Scotch whisky. In a January 12, 1968 issue of
The Saturday Evening Post, Capote wrote: After seeing a rough cut of the film, Capote recalled initially being upset about details that had been changed or added, but realized that if every detail had been exact to the book, the film would have been nine hours long. After the rough cut ended, Capote was disoriented because he had witnessed many of the events shown, including the executions of the murderers. Brooks was concerned that Capote would not like the film, but Capote thanked him for the work he had done.
Awards and nominations American Film Institute Lists: •
AFI's 10 Top 10 - #8 Courtroom Drama •
AFI's 100 Years... 100 Heroes & Villains - Perry Smith & Dick Hickock – Nominated Villains ==Miniseries==