In 2011 he sat on the controversial case brought by
ACS Law on behalf of
MediaCAT, relating to file downloading on
peer-to-peer filesharing networks. In 2012 he ruled on
Temple Island v New English Teas, a case where a photograph of an
AEC Routemaster London bus crossing
Westminster Bridge was found sufficiently similar to another photograph of the subject to constitute copyright infringement. In July 2012, Birss, sitting in the High Court, ruled that Samsung did not infringe Apple's registered design right in its
iPad tablet. The judgment mirrored the decision made earlier in the US by a jury. In October 2012 the
Court of Appeal upheld the judgment, including the publicity order imposed on Apple because it was necessary to clear up uncertainty in the market place after Apple took legal action in Germany against Samsung. The order required Apple to publicise that it had lost the case on its website and in the media. The Court of Appeal said: Birss is the first UK court of appeal judge to admit having used ChatGPT-generated content in a judgement. Saying he found it "Jolly useful" Source: The Law Gazette, 14 September 2023. https://www.lawgazette.co.uk/news/solicitor-condemns-judges-for-staying-silent-on-woeful-reforms/5117228.article ==Personal life==