From contemporary reviews,
Video compared the Atari VCS's
launch titles, and gave tank pong the highest rating of the variations on
Combat with a seven-and-one-half rating for Tank-Pong and Invisible Tank Pong, six-and-one-half for invisible tank game, and six for all the other variations. In comparison,
BlackJack and
Video Olympics received a ten and eight-and-one-half rating each, while
Basic Math,
Surround,
Street Racer, and
Star Ship all received lower ratings. By 1982, the game was receiving negative reception. Walter Lowe, Jr. ranked the game with a one-and-a-half star rating in ''Playboy's Guide to Rating Video Games
while Ken Uston in Buying and Beating the Home Video Games'' declared "It's not fair to be too critical because, after all, this cartridge is nearly five years old; and in this age of rapid computer technology, that makes it almost an antique." Craig Kubey's ''The Winners' Book of Video Games
simply described it as "adequate" with both Lowe, Jr. and Kubey both only finding the saving grace that it came included with the console. In the British publication TV Gamer'' from August 1983, Sonya Bradford found the controls took time to get used to and that the game "becomes a bit monotonous, which is not helped by the poor graphics." From retrospective reviews, Brett Alan Weiss of the online video game database
AllGame gave the game a four-and-a-half-star rating out of five, declaring that the simple graphics and sound fail to give a true impression of the game, noting its high replay value and "highly entertaining cat-and-mouse action." In the first issue of
Classic Gamer Magazine (1999) D.B. Caufield declared
Combat as "still an outstanding two-player game", finding that what it lacked in graphics it made up for in game play. In 1995,
Flux magazine ranked
Combat #48 on their list of "Top 100 Video Games". The article stated that despite what the publication described as poor-quality graphics, the game play made
Combat earn its position on the list. In 2012,
PCMag included
Combat in their "The Greatest Atari Games of All Time" list, with writer Eric Griffith noted the dated graphics by 2012 standards, while finding that the game felt "pretty magical in the 70's." ==Legacy==