Common schools typically taught "
the three Rs" (reading, [w]riting, and [a]rithmetic),
history,
geography, and
math. The
McGuffey Reader was the favorite schoolroom text in the 19th century, surpassing influence of Noah Webster's blue-backed speller. A strong emphasis on spiritual and moral lessons mixed into the text's lessons. There was wide variation in regard to grading (from 0-100 grading to no grades at all), but end-of-the-year
recitations were a common way that parents were informed about what their children were learning.
Moral instruction The intention of common schools was to equip every child with moral instruction and "equalize the conditions of men." The emphasis on morality in the classroom remained a strong element of education. As the fervor of the
Second Great Awakening declined, the instruments of teaching morality changed from overtly Biblical to an attempt at a neutral approach. Implementing the philosophy of
phrenology, moral instruction began to use a scientific approach and rejected the old dogmatic method of imparting moral instruction.
Controversy Although common schools were designed by
Horace Mann to be
nonsectarian, there were several fierce battles, most notably in
New York City and
Philadelphia, where
Roman Catholic immigrants and Native Americans objected to the use of the
King James Version of the Bible. Tensions were especially high in cities with large immigrant populations. In 1844, The Philadelphia Nativist riots (Bible Riots) began as a result of tensions between nativists and immigrants, due in part to a rumor that Catholic immigrants would remove Protestant Bibles from classroom curriculums. Even without Bible readings, most common schools taught children the general
Protestant values (e.g.,
work ethic) of 19th-century America. ==Common school era==