In 1953, Beth Israel purchased of land on Jamesbury Drive for $42,000 (today $), and began construction of their current building on it in 1958. Completed in 1959, the building cost $735,000 (today $), of which over $300,000 (today $) was
mortgaged. The building had a main sanctuary that sat 476, a chapel with seating for 110, and a social hall that could accommodate up to 950 people. For the
High Holidays, the sanctuary could be expanded into the social hall, providing seating for 1,450. The mortgage was retired in 15 years. The structure at 835 Pleasant Street was sold on September 10, 1959 to the Orthodox
Shaarai Torah Synagogue, to serve as its west side branch. Kazis was succeeded as congregational rabbi by Baruch Goldstein in 1971. A native of
Mława (then in
East Prussia), Goldstein had been sent to
Auschwitz concentration camp in 1942. His entire family perished in
the Holocaust, but he survived and emigrated to the
United States, where he became a rabbi. Goldstein was succeeded by Jay Rosenbaum in 1986. A graduate of
New York University and
Rutgers University, he had been ordained by the
Jewish Theological Seminary of America (JTSA) in 1980. ==1990s to present==