City directories from the years 1845 to 1853 list the congregation as having met at 156 Attorney Street. The first building constructed by Rodeph Sholom, at 8 Clinton Street on the
Lower East Side in 1853, is still in use by
Congregation Chasam Sopher. It is the second-oldest surviving synagogue building in New York City and the fifth-oldest synagogue building in the United States. Rodeph Sholom moved to
Lexington Avenue and 63rd Street, to a new Victorian Romanesque building designed by
D. & J. Jardine and built in 1872–73 for
Ansche Chesed. Simeon Abrahams conveyed land to the congregation for a burial ground in 1842. This cemetery was on 88th Street between Madison and Park Avenues. By 1879, there had not been a burial in twenty-six years. It was removed sometime between 1897 and 1911. The synagogue began as an
Orthodox congregation, and began using a
Conservative service in 1875.
Aaron Wise served as rabbi from 1876 to his death in 1896, followed by
Rudolph Grossman from 1896 until his death in 1927. The congregation joined the
Reform movement in 1901. The
Romanesque Revival synagogue house and sanctuary, designed by Charles B. Meyers, were built between 1929–30 and dedicated on
Purim in March 1930. Modern renovations to the lobby and multi-purpose room, overseen by
MBB Architects and Chicago-based Judaica expert Amy Reichert, improved the building's accessibility and introduced new artwork. Benjamin H. Spratt is the senior
rabbi. == Day school ==