Findlay first competed as a member of the U.S. Olympic
rowing team at the
1956 Summer Games. He won a gold medal in the
coxed pair event with
Dan Ayrault and
Kurt Seiffert of the
Stanford Cardinal. Findlay acted as rowing coach of the Stanford freshman team, and was subsequently named its
varsity coach in 1959. At the
Olympic Games the following year, he finished third in coxed pair. , Findlay is one of 11 individuals to win both the America's Cup and an Olympic medal. He is one of only two people to win the America's Cup and an Olympic gold medal in
rowing (the other being
Joseph Sullivan, who achieved this in 2017). Findlay's expertise in sailing and physical strength were valued by his fellow crew members on
Courageous. His proficiency at trimming sails, coupled with his ability to balance a long way over the water on the
trapeze, played a vital role in the Tempest team securing Olympic bronze. He participated in the tumultuous
1979 Fastnet race, which saw 15 yachtsmen die and dozens of ships capsize.
Kent Mitchell, his teammate during the 1960 and 1964 Olympics, described Findlay as having "just sailed right through it". Findlay was also a key member of the
Windward Passage, the award-winning Maxi Ocean Racer, for 12 years from 1974 until 1986. ==Post-competitive career==