Tribe Carpinieae, containing
Ostryopsis–
Carpinus–
Ostrya is defined by staminate flowers without a perianth, operculate pollen apertures with endexine not thickening at apertural region, a base chromosome number of 8, and a plicate leaf vernation pattern. Several characters, including
glabrous receptacle of staminate flowers, smooth nutlet surface, and secondary veins extending directly into leaf teeth, differentiate
Ostryopsis from
Carpinus and
Ostrya.
Ostryopsis is often considered the sister group of
Carpinus and
Ostrya, but its
phylogenetic position is debated. A close relationship with
Corylus is supported by wood anatomy characters and chloroplast gene sequences. The placement of
Ostryopsis as sister to the
Ostrya-
Carpinus clade is supported by a phylogenetic tree based on chloroplast DNA data but placement basal to
Corylus is supported in an ITS-based tree.
Carpinus is often considered sister to
Ostrya. DNA sequences suggest that
Carpinus might have differentiated from the extinct genus
Palaeocarpinus.
Carpinus is defined by several morphological characters including presence of pistillodes in the male florets, and leafy
bracts subtending the flowers and fruits.
Carpinus is divided into two sections,
Distegocarpus and
Carpinus, based on floral bracts,
infructescences, and scales. Section
Carpinus is further divided into three subsections –
Carpinus,
Monbeigianae and
Polyneurae. The monophyly of the genus is debatable. ITS data suggests the genus is paraphyletic while chloroplast DNA and nuclear 5S spacer data support it as monophyletic.
Carpinus may also be considered paraphyletic depending on the placement of
Ostrya.
Ostrya has a close relationship with
Carpinus, which is strongly supported by ITS and rbcL sequences and morphological and combined data from several studies. Although both genera share similar inflorescences, pollen grains and vessels with simple perforations, they differ in leaf epidermal characters and their infructescence bracts, which are radially symmetrical and inflated bladder-like in
Ostrya and are open and flat in
Carpinus. While the close relationship of
Carpinus and
Ostrya is supported by data, the monophyly of the two genera has remained controversial. Some studies have nested
Ostrya within
Carpinus between sections
Carpinus and
Distegocarpus on the basis of ITS data or placed
Ostrya as a basal grade to the
Carpinus clade on the basis of chloroplast DNA data. ==References==