The club was founded in 1877. Its first season was played under the name Vale of Strathmore; its first recorded match was a 3–0 defeat against
Strathmore (Dundee) in November 1877. The club's first captain was Louis Macfarlane, but after the change of name to Coupar Angus, the club elected George Robertson, a bank manager in Coupar Angus, as captain, and Macfarlane continued as one of the two full-backs. The club's first Scottish Cup tie was at
Rob Roy of
Callander, the side losing 1–0 after a match of "give and take" character. The
following season the club again lost to Rob Roy, albeit this time because the side was handicapped by an early collision between Macfarlane (playing for the match in goal) and "goal watcher" William Davidson, which saw the latter taken off the field and the former continuing while injured. Coupar Angus' first victory in the competition was in
1880–81, against Strathmore (Dundee), winning 4–1 in front of "a large number of spectators", in which every goal was scored in the first half. The club lost in the second round 3–0 at home to
Arbroath. Coupar Angus played in the first
Perthshire Cup in 1884–85, reaching the semi-final; Coupar Angus lost at home to
Vale of Teith, the visitors coming in "for a good amount of 'chaffing'" from the spectators, "the female portion especially being rather demonstrative". The club protested against the refereeing on four grounds; a) the referee did not award a goal for Coupar Angus that was "fully one foot over the goal-line", b) the referee awarded a goal to the Vale despite having blown his whistle for a foul, c) the second goal came 150 seconds after full-time should have been given (and 2 minutes after the referee said time should have been up), and d) "throughout the whole game [the referee's] partiality was glaringly manifested". The
Perthshire Football Association dismissed the protest, leaving Coupar Angus threatening to quit the association. In 1885–86, the club played in the first edition of the
Forfarshire Cup, but after a 6–1 second round defeat to
Strathmore (Arbroath) eschewed the competition to focus on the Perthshire. The club duly reached the final, played at the St Johnstone Recreation Ground, before a crowd of 1,500. With 15 minutes to go, Coupar Angus was 2–0 up, but ran out of stamina, and Dunblane scored three late goals - the second "a rather soft one" - to retain the trophy. Two months later, the club was involved in a frightening accident; on 1 May 1886, the club had hired a brake from the Coupar Angus Royal Hotel to bring it back from a match against
Lochee, but at Tullybaccart Hill one of the wheels gave way and the brake's occupants were ejected. None of the players was injured, but the driver, Donald M'Lean, broke his leg; complications set in and he died four days later. The club gained revenge on Dunblane in 1886–87, beating the Heather 3–1 at home in the semi-final of the Perthshire Cup, in a "rough and exciting" game that saw Dunblane protest about the behaviour of the spectators. In the final, again at St Johnstone's Park, the club beat
Fair City Athletics 2–1, to lift the Perthshire Cup for the only time. Coupar Angus also reached the third round of the national cup
that season for the first time, but this was because Fair City Athletics did not turn up to the first round tie and the club drew a bye in the second. In the third, the club lost 3–2 at
Erin Rovers of
Perth, all five goals coming in the second half. The club made the third round again the
following season, after recording its biggest Cup win of 9–2 against
Blairgowrie Our Boys, and again getting the benefit of a bye. In the third the club lost to
Dundee Wanderers by its then-biggest Scottish Cup defeat of 8–0. In
1889–90, the club equalled its defeat, against Fair City Athletics in the second round of the Cup. To the surprise of most, Coupar Angus turned the result around in the Perthshire Cup three weeks later, being 5–3 up at home to the F.C.A. with ten minutes remaining, when visiting supporters invaded the pitch in protest at an injury, leaving Coupar Angus "in a state of riot" after 200 Perth "rowdies" ran amok. Coupar Angus went on to the final, beating
Crieff 10–1 away in the semi-final thanks to seven goals for Lawson. In the final, the club lost to
St Johnstone at Balhousie Park; Coupar Angus took an early lead, and the score remained 1–1 at half-time, but four quick second half goals sent the cup to Perth for the first time. In 1891–92, the
Scottish Football Association introduced qualifying rounds. That season, the club reached the penultimate round before the competition proper, but scratched to Dunblane. Its defeat in the first preliminary round in 1892–93 to Blairgowrie Our Boys was the club's final Scottish Cup tie. The club continued into the 1893–94 season, but did not enter the Scottish Cup, and its final competitive match was a 6–0 defeat at
Tulloch in the Perthshire Cup. The name was revived on at least two further occasions, the current
Coupar Angus F.C. side being a
Junior club. ==Colours==