Cracker Island received generally positive reviews. On
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalised rating out of 100 to reviews from professional publications, it received an
average score of 80, based on 23 reviews, indicating generally favourable reviews. The aggregator website AnyDecentMusic? gave the album a 7.1 out of 10, based on their assessment of the critical consensus. Reviewing
Cracker Island for
AllMusic,
Stephen Thomas Erlewine called it "less an exploration of new sonic territory so much as it is a reaffirmation of [Damon Albarn's] strengths" and felt that "there's a clean, efficient energy propelling
Cracker Island that gives the album a fresh pulse." Writing for
Clash, Emma Harrison wrote that it "is more akin to a sprint as opposed to a marathon on the virtual virtuosos' eighth studio album ... despite its diminutive length,
Cracker Island packs one hell of a punch and spans genres far and wide." In
DIY, Lisa Wright declared the album "very much a set piece that prioritises concept and narrative, resulting in one of Gorillaz's most restrained, contemplative releases yet - one that will perhaps appeal to fans of Albarn's solo work more than devotees of his monkeys' more genre-hopping forays." In
Pitchfork, Ben Cardew said
Cracker Island "walks a very thin line between playing to the band's strengths and relying too heavily on old tricks". In
Slant Magazine, Paul Attard wrote: "When left to his own devices (and stripped of his usual slew of
Tumblr-approved guests), Albarn engineers some of
Cracker Islands most stand-out material, albeit ones that still vary greatly in quality. Songs like the Greg Kurstin-produced 'Tarantula' and 'Skinny Ape,' while still containing some unnecessary passages (most conspicuously the latter's
ska breakdown), are comparatively barebones and cleanly produced. Even better is '
Baby Queen,' a gorgeous piece of
dream-pop that cuts back on Albarn's worst theatrical tendencies." == Track listing ==