Crumb was met with wide acclaim from critics, earning a 95% rating on
Rotten Tomatoes based on 43 reviews, with an average score of 8.4/10. The website's critical consensus reads, "
Crumb is a frank and surreal chronicle of artistic expression and family trauma, offering an unblinking gaze into the mind and work of cartoonist Robert Crumb that will endear as much as it unsettles."
Gene Siskel rated it as the best film of the year.
Roger Ebert gave it four stars (out of four), writing: "
Crumb is a film that gives new meaning to the notion of art as therapy." Critic Jeffrey M. Anderson gave it four stars (out of four), calling it "one of the bravest and most honest films I've ever seen", and listing its characteristics as those of "a great documentary". In
The Washington Post,
Desson Howe's review was similarly positive. The
San Francisco Chronicle rated the film as "wild applause", with critic Edward Guthmann calling it "one of the most provocative, haunting documentaries of the last decade." He also noted that Robert Crumb and wife Aline had drawn a "scornful" cartoon about the film in
The New Yorker. Despite such strong reviews,
Crumb was not nominated for the
Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature (the nominating committee reportedly stopped watching the film after only twenty minutes). The Oscar snub of
Crumb, following the snubbing of the equally acclaimed
Hoop Dreams the previous year, caused a media furor that caused the
Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences to revamp its documentary nomination process. Zwigoff stated in an interview that "the Academy Awards thing had much more to do with the fact that at the time, a lot of the documentary membership was made up of distributors of documentary films. The rules have changed since then. But they would just vote for the films they distributed because it was in their financial interest to do so. I came to learn that later. At the time, I just assumed they were disgusted with the film." In 2008,
Entertainment Weekly named
Crumb the 14th best film of the last 25 years. In 2012,
Slant Magazine ranked the film #74 on its list of the 100 Best Films of the 1990s, calling it "Arguably the greatest of all nonfiction films." Although Zwigoff only filmed Robert Crumb's brothers with their consent, some have questioned whether they were able to provide that consent in a meaningful way.
Awards The film won several major critical accolades awarded for films released in 1995, including: •
Sundance Film Festival –
Grand Jury Prize Documentary •
National Board of Review – Best Documentary •
National Society of Film Critics –
Best Non-Fiction Film •
New York Film Critics –
Best Documentary •
Los Angeles Film Critics –
Best Non-Fiction Film •
Boston Film Critics – Best Documentary •
International Documentary Association – Best Feature ==See also==