Giancarlo Zappoli of mymovies.it stated that the film's two strengths were its notable cast and the foray into fantasy and sci-fi (unusual for contemporary Italian films) but that the screenplay suffered from an abundance of
subplots. Valerio Molinaro of
Corriere spettacolo praised the film's
scenography and its "first-rate choral cast" but found the screenplay "not always up to par". Antonio Palazzo of
extratek.com commented that the film "is an ambitious all-Italian Blockbuster, with an excellent background story" and good performances from "world-famous actors" but that the screenplay was often confusing and that the film's running time did not allow the story to develop as it should have. Fiaba Di Martino of
Film TV magazine criticized the screenplay and the underwritten characters, and compared the movie to an overenthusiastic
fan film made for
YouTube. Martina Catrambone of
themacguffin.it wrote that the writing, editing, music, and special effects did not make any sense, and stated that such a film proved that Italian cinema should avoid
science fiction. Alberto Mutignani of the online magazine
The Walk of Fame called it "the worst film of the year", stating that the film ended up being an unintentional comedy, with a story so confusing that one wondered if some scenes were missing.
Creators: the Past ranked ninth at the Italian box office during its first weekend, earning 69,000 euros. Some sources say it earned between 120,000 and 130,000 euros before its release was cut short by the resurging COVID-19 pandemic. The revenue for the producers, after deduction of ticket sales fees, was reported to be a mere 47,000 euros. In January 2021, director Piergiuseppe Zaia stated that despite the film's aborted release, he and Fani were working on what would be the second installment of the trilogy. However, his production company, Artuniverse, was liquidated in December 2023 due to its inability to generate revenues. In 2025, Zaia said that he was no longer involved in filmmaking. ==Controversies==