In Issue 49 of the British wargaming magazine
Perfidious Albion, Geoffrey Barnard noted several issues with the American publisher's use (or misuse) of British units, pointing out in one instance that one British regiment should have had nine
Bren guns but in fact were only supplied with two. But about the game itself, Barnard concluded, "
Squad Leader/
Cross of Iron/
Crescendo of Doom is not so much a game, but more a way of life ... the game now contains more detail, rules and counter-types than most gamers will be able to use in a lifetime." In his 1980 book
The Best of Board Wargaming,
Nick Palmer commented, "Play can be very bloodthirsty, and is nearly always exciting." Palmer gave this game an Excitement rating of 90%. In a sidebar, Geoff Barnard agreed, writing, "
Squad Leader and its expansions is very much a system with components rather than a mere game, and while the [overall] package is so detailed as to be almost indigestible, the player is free to use what detail he wants as he see fit." In Issue 51 of
Moves, John Alsen did an in-depth review of the new rules, terrain, counters and each of the 11 scenarios, then concluded, "
Crescendo of Doom is a worthy successor to
Cross of Iron. There are no major problems with the rules ... This is a package with the potential to provide many hours of enjoyment to those interested in the period." In
Campaign Special Issue #2, Lorrin Bird commented, "While the original
Squad Leader game was a work of art with regard to its fine balance of playability and detail...the gamettes are coming to represent the 'masterpieces' of wargamedom due to the unbelievable trivia that is included." Bird concluded, "The end result of the amazing efforts being made to make the
SL system as complete as possible is that one is presented with tanks which act pretty much like they did in real life." ==Awards==