Critical response The New York Times film critic T. M. Pierce gave the film a mixed review, writing, "A tough, mildly exciting melodrama about gangsters and a dame named Anna who 'gets into the blood' of a guy named Steve and causes him no end of trouble...In many ways
Criss Cross is a suspenseful action picture, due to the resourceful directing of Robert Siodmak. But it also is tedious and plodding at times, due partly to Mr. Siodmak's indulgence of a script that is verbose, redundant and imitative. However, the writers should be credited with having invested the old triangle-gangster formula with a couple of fresh if not exactly revolutionary twists." The film was reissued by Universal-International in 1959.
Reappraisal In 2004, film critic Dennis Schwartz wrote, "Robert Siodmak ... directs this cynical film noir of obsessive love and betrayal. It's 1940s film noir at its most influential as far as style goes, that is further enhanced by the beautiful dark photography of Frank Planer, the tight script by Daniel Fuchs, and the taut pacing by Siodmak. It's based on a story by Don Tracy ... Siodmak keeps the suspense at a feverish pitch, and the characterizations are well drawn out.
Criss Cross is one of the great examples of 1940s film noir at its most tragic. A must see film for fans of the genre." Dave Kehr, film critic for the
Chicago Reader, lauded the film and wrote, "Robert Siodmak was one of the most influential stylists of the 40s, helping to create, in films such as
Phantom Lady and
The Killers, the characteristic look of American film noir. But most of his films have nothing more than their pictorial qualities to recommend them—
Criss Cross being one of the few exceptions, an archly noir story replete with triple and quadruple crosses, leading up to one of the most shockingly cynical endings in the whole genre." Film Noir Foundation founder
Eddie Muller lists
Criss Cross as No. 2 in his Top 25 Noir Films saying: "Stupidly, I used to think there was something missing at the core. But it keeps getting better every time I see it. De Carlo in the parking lot pleading straight to the camera might be noir's defining moment." He continues: "Robert Siodmak... had a flair for compositions and camera movements ominous yet elegant. Images simultaneously enticing and foreboding are essential to noir, and Siodmak crafted them like nobody's business. From the first shot... Siodmak infuses the drama with a dreaminess that gets under your skin like a narcotic." On the review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, 92% of critics gave the film a positive review, based on 12 reviews.
Awards Nomination • Edgar Allan Poe Awards: Edgar, Best Motion Picture, Daniel Fuchs and Don Tracy (novel); 1950. ==Adaptation==