Steve Greenlee of
JazzTimes stated "It’s been five years since Dave Holland’s quintet released an album of new material. The bassist hasn’t exactly been relaxing in the meantime; he put out two albums of big-band music and toured extensively, and released a stellar double-live CD by his quintet. And all the while, the least grateful among us have been hankering for some new music from Holland’s quintet. Well, here it is, and it holds its own against
Prime Directive, the group’s most impressive release... The
groupthink mentality manifests itself most obviously on the New Orleans tribute “Easy Did It,” for which Holland and Smith create a slithering, swelling rhythm that culminates in a five-way roundtable of near-chaos.
Critical Mass will be on everyone’s list of 2006’s best." John Kelman of
All About Jazz wrote, "Proof that it's possible to retain one's identity while breaking new ground,
Critical Mass continues a streak of winning records for Holland that shows no sign of letting up."
John Fordham of
The Guardian added, " It's unflinching contemporary instrumental jazz, but as subtly melodic as Holland's bands always are." ==Track listing==