The series received mixed reviews.
Bloody Disgusting gave the series one-and-a-half skulls, declaring the "CG effects are so
Syfy-level bad that they wouldn’t have even passed muster back in the ’90s" and the episodes "absolutely loaded with that bargain basement effects work" and "lowbrow humor".
JoBlo gave the series a 6 out of 10, saying that "there's going to be a split reaction to
A New Binge. I don't think the story crafted by Rubin and his co-writers Al Kaplan and Jon Kaplan is one that anybody was expecting to see told in this franchise". Ultimately, the review felt it was "a very innocuous piece of entertainment". ==References==