Background Crown Heights—Utica Avenue station was constructed as part of the Eastern Parkway Line. The line's section to Atlantic Avenue was part of Contract 2 of the
Interborough Rapid Transit Company (IRT)'s plan to construct an extension of the original subway, Contract 1. Contract 2 extended the original line from City Hall in Manhattan to Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn. The Board of Rapid Transit Commissioners approved the route on September 27, 1900, and the contract was signed on September 11, 1902. Construction commenced on Contract 2 on March 4, 1903. The first section opened on January 9, 1908, extending the subway from Bowling Green to Borough Hall. On April 28, 1908, the IRT formally applied with the
New York Public Service Commission for permission to open the final section of the Contract 2 line from
Borough Hall to
Atlantic Avenue near the
Flatbush Avenue LIRR station. The application was approved, and the IRT extension opened on May 1, 1908. and extended to
Atlantic Avenue in 1908, was to be extended eastward into Brooklyn. The line was to be extended along
Flatbush Avenue and
Eastern Parkway to Buffalo Street as a four-track subway line, and then along East 98th Street and Livonia Avenue to New Lots Avenue as an elevated two-track line, with provisions for the addition of a third track. In addition, a two-track branch line along Nostrand Avenue branching off east of the
Franklin Avenue station was to be constructed. The underground portion of the line became known as the Eastern Parkway Line, or Route 12, while the elevated portion became known as the New Lots Line.
Construction and opening The IRT Eastern Parkway Line was built as part of Route 12 from 1915 to 1918. On August 23, 1920, the Eastern Parkway Line was extended from Atlantic Avenue to Crown Heights–Utica Avenue, with the Utica Avenue station opening at this time. The new trains would be served by trains from Seventh Avenue. On November 22, 1920, the first portion of the
IRT New Lots Line opened between Utica Avenue and Junius Street opened on November 22, 1920, with shuttle trains operating over this route.
Later years The
New York City Board of Transportation announced plans in November 1949 to extend platforms at several IRT stations, including Utica Avenue, to accommodate all doors on ten-car trains. Although ten-car trains already operated on the line, the rear car could not open its doors at the station because the platforms were so short. A renovation of the Utica Avenue station was funded as part of the MTA's 1980–1984 capital plan. The MTA received a $106 million grant from the
Urban Mass Transit Administration in October 1983; most of the grant would fund the renovation of eleven stations, including Utica Avenue. including Utica Avenue. The MTA announced in 2024 that it would replace the station's existing
waist-high turnstiles with taller, wide-aisle turnstiles. In April 2025, the MTA announced plans to install taller fare gates with glass panels at 20 stations, including the Crown Heights–Utica Avenue station. The fare gates would be manufactured by
Cubic Transportation Systems,
Conduent,
Scheidt & Bachmann, and STraffic as part of a pilot program to reduce fare evasion. ==Station layout==