Curtain Call 2 was met with generally favorable reviews from critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album received an
average score of 74, based on four reviews.
AllMusic's
Stephen Thomas Erlewine praised the album, saying that it is "generous to a fault, playing like an endless streaming playlist instead of a curated compilation, yet it does feature many highlights from Eminem's mid-career records". Grant Jones of RapReviews.com wrote: "The 'Eminem sound' the first
Curtain Call could accurately collate and celebrate (given 100% of it was produced by either
Dre or Em) has been pushed aside in favor of party trick flows and quick-win hooks from guests. It still seems to be a successful approach, but it's not as satisfying to revisit". Drew Millard of
Pitchfork stated: "despite showcasing some of Eminem's stylistic growing pains,
Curtain Call 2 isn't completely lined with duds". In his mixed review, Robin Murray of
Clash wrote: "
Curtain Call 2 is at its most engaging when the
Detroit figure simply cuts back on the
Billboard tie-ins, and reminds us all why he became such a revered rapper in the first place. ... As a project, however,
Curtain Call 2 is weighed down by its flaws. There's no ignoring the wayward path Eminem has taken over the past two decades, and the tracklisting reflects this". == Commercial performance ==