Candy Cummings, a star pitcher in the 1860s and 1870s, is widely credited with inventing the curveball. In his biography of Cummings, Stephen Katz provides proof. Several other pitchers of Cummings's era claimed to have invented the curveball. One was Fred Goldsmith. Goldsmith maintained that he gave a demonstration of the pitch on August 16, 1870, at the
Capitoline Grounds in
Brooklyn,
New York, and that renowned sportswriter
Henry Chadwick had covered it in the
Brooklyn Eagle on August 17, 1870. However, Stephen Katz, in his biography of Cummings, shows that Goldsmith's claim was not credible, and that Goldsmith's reference to an article by Chadwick in the
Brooklyn Eagle was likely fabricated. Other claimants to invention of the curveball are shown by Katz to have gotten the curveball only after Cummings, or not to have been pitching curveballs.
John Thorn, the Official Baseball Historian of
Major League Baseball, credits
Joseph McElroy Mann of
Princeton University as the first known college baseball player to master the curveball. About 1872, another
Princeton man, James Winthrop Hageman, of the class of 1872, was reputed to be a curve ball pitcher, but it was his change of pace that fooled the batsmen. It was not until "Mac" Mann made a scientific study of the art that players began to realize its full value. "The fact that so many professionals seemed ignorant of curve pitching and hurried to see Mann proves conclusively that the Princetonian was the first to use the curve with any judgment and control over the ball". Mann is also credited with pitching the first no-run, no-hit game in the annals of baseball. In 1876, the second known collegiate baseball player to perfect the curveball was
Clarence Emir Allen of Western Reserve College, now known as
Case Western Reserve University, where he never lost a game. Both Allen, and teammate pitcher John P. Barden, became famous for employing the curve in the late 1870s. In the early 1880s,
Clinton Scollard (1860–1932), a pitcher from
Hamilton College in New York, became famous for his curve ball and later earned fame as a prolific American poet. In 1885,
St. Nicholas, a children's magazine, featured a story entitled, "How Science Won the Game". It told of how a boy pitcher mastered the curveball to defeat the opposing batters. The
New York Clipper reported, of a September 26, 1863, game at
Princeton University (then the College of New Jersey), that F. P. Henry's "slow pitching with a great twist to the ball achieved a victory over fast pitching". However, Katz, in his biography of Cummings, explains that Henry was not actually pitching curveballs.
Harvard president
Charles Eliot was among those opposed to the curve, claiming it was a dishonest practice unworthy of Harvard students. At an athletics conference at Yale University in 1884 a speaker (thought to be from Harvard, likely Charles Eliot Norton, a cousin of the Harvard president) was reported to have stated: "For the pitcher, instead of delivering the ball to the batter in an honest, straightforward way, that the latter may exert his strength to the best advantage in knocking it, now uses every effort to deceive him by curving—I think that is the word—the ball. And this is looked upon as the last triumph of athletic science and skill. I tell you it is time to call halt! when the boasted progress in athletics is in the direction of fraud and deceit". In the past, major league pitchers
Tommy Bridges,
Bob Feller,
Virgil Trucks,
Herb Score,
Camilo Pascual,
Sandy Koufax,
Bert Blyleven, and the aforementioned
Dwight Gooden were regarded as having outstanding curveballs. == See also ==