The one-dimensional cyclic cellular automaton has been extensively studied by Robert Fisch, a student of Griffeath. Starting from a random configuration with
n = 3 or
n = 4, this type of rule can produce a pattern which, when presented as a time-space diagram, shows growing triangles of values competing for larger regions of the grid. The boundaries between these regions can be viewed as moving particles which collide and interact with each other. In the three-state cyclic cellular automaton, the boundary between regions with values
i and
i + 1 (mod
n) can be viewed as a particle that moves either leftwards or rightwards depending on the ordering of the regions; when a leftward-moving particle collides with a rightward-moving one, they
annihilate each other, leaving two fewer particles in the system. This type of
ballistic annihilation process occurs in several other cellular automata and related systems, including
Rule 184, a cellular automaton used to model
traffic flow. The long-term behavior of this rule is
exactly solvable. If two of the three values each have an initial density of 0 ≤
p ≤ 1/2, then at time
t the mean cluster size is
asymptotically equal to \sqrt{\pi t / 2 p}. In the
n = 4 automaton, the same two types of particles and the same annihilation reaction occur. Additionally, a boundary between regions with values
i and
i + 2 (mod
n) can be viewed as a third type of particle, that remains stationary. A collision between a moving and a stationary particle results in a single moving particle moving in the opposite direction. Beginning at an initial state with equal densities for all values, the mean cluster size obeys a
power law with exponent around 0.3467. However, for
n ≥ 5, random initial configurations tend to stabilize quickly rather than forming any non-trivial long-range dynamics. Griffeath has nicknamed this dichotomy between the long-range particle dynamics of the
n = 3 and
n = 4 automata on the one hand, and the static behavior of the
n ≥ 5 automata on the other hand, "Bob's dilemma", after Bob Fisch. == Two or more dimensions ==