Reviews at its release were generally positive, if dismissive. Otto Preminger himself stated that he forgot he had made the film.
Variety's review stated that the central "triangle, in which Dana Andrews and Henry Fonda fight it out for the love of Joan Crawford, is basically a shallow lending-library affair, but it's made to seem important by the magnetic trio's slick-smart backgrounds - plus, of course, excellent direction, sophisticated dialog, solid supporting cast, and other flashy production values." T. M. P. in
The New York Times noted, "Miss Crawford is, of course, an old hand at being an emotionally confused and frustrated woman, and she plays the role with easy competence."
Otis L. Guernsey, Jr. in the
New York Herald Tribune commented, "Preminger accomplishes no mean feat in guiding these people in and out among the interweavings of their own complexes, and he does wonders in varying the action of similar scenes." Initial dismissal of
Daisy Kenyon has given way to some critical reappraisal in recent years; it has earned a cult following, with some calling it a misunderstood
masterpiece and one of Preminger's best films. Dan Callahan of
Slant, awarding
Daisy Kenyon three and a half stars out of four, called the film a "troubling and ambiguous portrayal of three real, unknowable characters (and actors) in constant flux", saying that the film "distilled [soap opera] to its real life essence, until what's left is nothing more than the ultimate mystery of art." Chris Fujiwara, in a 2015 study of Preminger's films, draws attention to the fact that
Daisy Kenyon is "possibly the first Hollywood film to allude to the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II." Dan, partly in an attempt to impress Daisy, takes a pro-bono case for a Japanese American war veteran whose land was confiscated while he was away fighting. Dan is physically attacked in the course of the case and ultimately loses it. The original screenplay had a scene depicting a racist judge, but the film censor
Joseph Breen did not allow it.
Daisy Kenyon holds an 86% rating on review aggregation website
Rotten Tomatoes, based on seven reviews. Critics Roundup, a website that described itself as "the first movie review aggregator to select reviews based on writing quality instead of popularity", reported that 100% of 12 critics reviewed the film positively. The assessment is available through the Wayback machine. The website ceased to exist several years ago. ==References==