According to
TechCrunch, the show received over 4.5 million downloads by the end of September 2017. According to the
Daily Utah Chronicle, the podcast had a 4.5 out of 5 stars on
Apple Podcasts in February 2018. Megan Summers wrote in
Screen Rant that the show is "horror audio drama at its best." Simon Hill wrote in
Wired that the show was a "memorably thrilling ride." Freddy McConnell commented on episode number six entitled "Horns Limo Service," saying that the episode "has stomach-turning sound effects and brilliantly blunt forensic pathologist chat." In her
Podcast Magazine review, Michele Pariza Wacek criticized the podcast for the use of narration because the narration was an unexplained component of the show that interrupted the flow of the story. Chelsea Tatham wrote in the
Tampa Bay Times that the podcast "feels like a television show for your ears." == References ==