Buffalo Bills Cloutier was selected by the
Dallas Cowboys in the eighteenth round (242nd overall) of the
1962 NFL draft, but after failing to come to terms with the Cowboys, he chose to sign as an
undrafted free agent with the
Buffalo Bills of the
American Football League on January 4,
1962. He was tried at
offensive end to take advantage of his speed, before suffering an ankle injury and being later waived.
Portland Sea Hawks In 1962, after being released from the Buffalo Bills, Cloutier signed with the
Portland Sea Hawks of the
Atlantic Coast Football League (ACFL). He resigned with the team for the 1963 season.
Boston Patriots On March 3,
1964, Cloutier signed with the
Boston Patriots of the
American Football League (AFL). He became the first Maine native to play for the franchise. Cloutier was converted into a
free safety. He was cut on September 8, but was later re-signed. He was mostly used as a punt returner on
special teams. He started in the
American Football Conference Championship game against the Buffalo Bills. He was released on August 31,
1965. ==Personal life==