Celtic In January 2019, Gutman signed a contract with Rangers'
long-time rivals,
Celtic. On January 19, 2019, he played in a
friendly for Celtic reserve side as a trialist in a 3–4 loss to
Arbroath. On January 31, 2019, Celtic announced that it had signed Gutman to a three-year contract. He was immediately loaned to
Nashville SC in the
USL Championship for the 2019 season. Nashville rescinded their acceptance of Gutman on loan on February 2, citing
Major League Soccer's disapproval of the loan.
Charlotte Independence (loan) A week later after the Nashville loan was called off, it was announced by
The Charlotte Post that Gutman would be joining the
Charlotte Independence of the
USL Championship on loan for the
2019 USL Championship season, the second tier of soccer in the U.S. On March 15, 2019, Gutman made his debut with Charlotte scoring a second half goal in a 3–2 loss to
Indy Eleven. On April 16, 2019, Gutman opened the scoring for Charlotte in a 2–1 victory over
Bethlehem Steel FC. On June 15, 2019, Gutman helped Charlotte to a 4–1 victory over
Birmingham Legion, scoring the opening goal of the match.
FC Cincinnati (loan) On August 3, 2019, Gutman was loaned to
Major League Soccer side
FC Cincinnati through the 2020 MLS season. As part of the transaction, Cincinnati sent $50,000 of General Allocation Money (GAM) to the Chicago Fire in exchange for Gutman's MLS rights and a third-round pick in the
2020 MLS SuperDraft. In addition, the Fire could receive up to an additional $150,000 in GAM if Gutman was added to FC Cincinnati's roster and met certain performance-based metrics and would receive a percentage of any future revenue should FC Cincinnati transfer or loan Gutman outside of MLS. On August 10, 2019, Gutman made his
Major League Soccer debut for Cincinnati, appearing as a starter in a 2–2 draw with
Columbus Crew.
Atlanta United On December 17, 2020, he was selected by
Atlanta United in Stage 1 of the
2020 MLS Re-Entry Draft. On March 9, 2021, Gutman was signed permanently by
Major League Soccer club
Atlanta United on a three-year deal from Celtic.
New York Red Bulls (loan) On March 9, 2021, Gutman was signed by
Atlanta United and then immediately loaned to the
New York Red Bulls for the
2021 season. On April 25, 2021, he scored his first goal for New York in a 3–2 loss to
Los Angeles Galaxy. On October 2, 2021, Gutman scored the lone goal in New York's 1–0 victory over his former club
FC Cincinnati.
Colorado Rapids On July 5, 2023, Gutman was acquired by the
Colorado Rapids in exchange for $400,000 in guaranteed
General Allocation Money (GAM), a conditional $150,000 in GAM if he were to reach certain performance metrics, and an international roster slot. He made his debut on July 8, 2023, against
FC Dallas.
Chicago Fire FC On December 12, 2023,
Chicago Fire FC acquired Gutman from Colorado in exchange for defender
Miguel Navarro and $450,000 in
General Allocation Money ($225,000 in 2024 & $225,000 in 2025). He made his debut for Chicago on February 24, 2024 against the
Philadelphia Union at
Subaru Park in Chester, Pa. ==Career statistics==