, the
review aggregators
Rotten Tomatoes and
Metacritic positively rated the series between 57–65 percent; the former published a score of 65 percent based on 20 reviews with an average rating of 6.2/10, while the latter published a
weighted average score of 57 out of 100 based on 26 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews".
David Bianculli broadly praised
Raines, calling for NBC to renew the brand-new show after having seen only two episodes.
Media Life Andrew Lyons called
Raines a fresh injection of
film noir sensibilities into the world of "
Bruckheimer quick cuts". Comparing Raines to characters played by
Humphrey Bogart and
Robert Mitchum, Lyons called Yost's take successful. For the
New York Post,
Raines was the only standout among the 2007 mid-season replacements that otherwise with […] horrible writing, amateurish acting and plot lines that stink up the joint." Linda Stasi described this cream of that crop as an amalgamation of other lasting serials such as
Columbo,
Medium, and
Monk. Invoking those same shows,
USA Today Robert Bianco was pleased with the Goldblum vehicle, further lauding Yost's "fascination with the beauty and peculiarity of Los Angeles. This is
Raymond Chandler for the Age of Therapy." Brian Lowry of
Variety called
Raines unremarkable in its field, with only
Jeff Goldblum to distinguish it, conceding that his analysis also fit the popular shows
House (with
Hugh Laurie) and
Monk (with
Tony Shalhoub). Lowry appreciated
Raines eschewing
mysticism in favor of Raines' acknowledged hallucinations. The
Toronto Star Vinay Menon similarly called Goldblum the show's driver, but that the performance "sometimes feels locked inside the wrong car." Though the
San Francisco Chronicle anticipated a quick cancellation for
Raines for its predictability, pandering, and mediocrity, reviewer Tim Goodman nonetheless called it an "enjoyable time waster", praising Goldblum and the show's "crisp, darkly saturated visual style".
Alessandra Stanley thought
Raines was an overly slavish
homage to 1986's
The Singing Detective; while she was uncertain about the hallucination gimmick—noting that most television
detectives have been strong men with faults (e.g.
Kojak with his
lollipop or
Ironside in his
wheelchair)—Stanley felt
Raines was trying to be too much and was muddled therefor. She did recommend allowing Goldblum's new vehicle to find its feet, though, much like
House,
Boston Legal, and
Shark did. Scott D. Pierce of the
Deseret News found
Raines to simply be a boring, "fairly standard
detective show" that cribbed from other, more-successful programs like
The Sopranos. Ellen Gray wrote in
The Philadelphia Inquirer that the well-trod hallucinating character trope only served to make Raines an unappealing character to audiences, and this failing central tenet of the show doomed it from the start. ==References==