British indologist
James Mallinson, recognising that White's "wide-ranging scholarship on
tantra,
yoga and
alchemy has inspired many students and scholars to undertake research in those fields", criticizes White in a piece entitled ''The Yogīs' Latest Trick''. Mallinson notes White ignores "almost everything that argues against his position" and "where contradictions to his thesis are noted, they are dismissed with
hubris." Mallinson says that White conflates the practice of yoga with the
siddhis that it produces. Mallinson further states "As well as varying the criteria for what constitutes yoga to suit his thesis, White cherry-picks his evidence to do the same, citing passages that support his argument while ignoring those in the very same texts that would argue against it." Pandita Indrani Rampersad accuses White of demolishing tantra. She also accuses
Wendy Doniger of preventing criticism of White. Larson notes and then criticizes two of White's main theses, namely that "neither
Bhakti nor
Vedanta were mainstream, rather Tantra was true 'mainstream' South Asian religiosity from 7th century CE to the beginning of the modern era", and that there is a need for "revisioning" of scholarly views on the historic religious Hindu and Buddhist practice in South Asia. Larson critiques these theories, stating that South Asia has been a "mind bogglingly" diverse, ancient and culturally rich region of the world, and claims of Tantra or any specific ideology being "mainstream" is neither persuasively presented by White nor reasonable. Further, adds Larson, the stated goal and call in White's book about the need for "revisionism" fails to properly appreciate the "rich diversity of South Asian spirituality", a persistent problem in
Indology whether it be demands for revisionism from colonial, reformist, bhakti or another point of view. White is right, says Larson, in pulling Indology scholarship out of the "Bhakti was mainstream" trap, but then creates and trips into a new trap of "Tantra was mainstream". Larson cautions about
Freudian eroticism and
transference issues, and states that Tantra is more than sex, sexuality is likely to be
allegorical in Tantric text known only to the initiate, not literal as described in White's book. ==Works==