Another reason for decanting wine is to
aerate it, or allow it to "breathe". The decanter is meant to mimic the effects of swirling the wine glass to stimulate the oxidation processes which triggers the release of more aromatic compounds. It is thought to benefit the wine by smoothing some of the harsher aspects of the wine (like
tannins or potential
wine faults like
mercaptans). Many wine writers, such as
Karen MacNeil, in the book
The Wine Bible, advocate decanting for aeration, especially with very tannic wines like
Barolo,
Bordeaux,
Cabernet Sauvignon,
Port, and
Rhône wines while noting that decanting could be harmful for more delicate wines like
Chianti and
Pinot noir. The effectiveness of decanting is a topic of debate, with some wine experts such as
oenologist Émile Peynaud, claiming that the prolonged exposure to oxygen diffuses and dissipates more aroma compounds than it stimulates, in contrast to the effects of the smaller scale exposure and immediate release that swirling the wine in a drinker's glass has. In line with the view that decanting can dissipate aromas, the wine expert,
Kerin O'Keefe, prefers to let the wine evolve slowly and naturally in the bottle, by uncorking it a few hours ahead, a practice suggested by wine producers such as
Bartolo Mascarello and
Franco Biondi Santi. Other wine experts, such as writer
Jancis Robinson, tout the
aesthetic value of using a decanter, especially one with an elegant design and made with clear glass, and believe that for all but the most fragile of wines that there is not much significant damage to the wine by decanting it. ==See also==