Early history The land making up Deep Cut Gardens was first settled by Europeans after the
Monmouth Tract was granted to
Quaker settlers in 1665. The site was divided into several family farms until 1890, when the town sheriff took over the property due to unpaid taxes. The land subsequently passed through several interim owners before being purchased by New York businessman Edward Dangler and his wife Teresa for $38,000 in 1926. In 1928, the Danglers built a two-storey, eight-room
Colonial Revival mansion on a hilltop overlooking the property and with views of
Sandy Hook and New York Harbor.
Genovese ownership In 1935, the Dangler mansion was sold to the mobster
Vito Genovese, who was looking for a summer home and a place where his three children could be "out in the country". To landscape the grounds, Genovese hired landscape architect Theodore Stoudt to plan a new garden surrounding the house. Over the next two years, Stoudt would end up directing "a small army of stonemasons, carpenters, landscapers and nurserymen" to transform the property. Stoudt, during an interview in 1991, recalled that he "saw the garden design as a mixture of English and Italian", and did not think an
Italian garden would "suit the house — or the Don's wallet." Therefore, Stoudt opted to build a "pseudo-Italian" rock garden on the steep slope behind the house, with terraced water pools, large
Sargent's weeping hemlocks and the Vesuvius replica. In addition to the landscaping, Genovese also constructed a large swimming pool, a three-hole golf course, two tennis courts and a greenhouse. Nevertheless, by 1937, Genovese's fortunes had taken a turn for the worse. After allegedly ordering the murder of fellow mobster Ferdinand Boccia, and with New York prosecutor
Thomas E. Dewey singling out Genovese as a target, Genovese fled to Europe. The fire, which required of hoses and two hours to extinguish, resulted in the complete loss of the mansion and an estimated $80,000 worth of damages, although the gardener's cottage and greenhouse were saved. and built a
ranch-style house on the site of the former mansion, moving in December 1954. Marjorie, who was the daughter of
Thomas Sperry, was an avid horticulturist and restored the dilapidated Genovese-era rock garden and greenhouse, After Karl's death in 1970, Marjorie approached the
Monmouth County Park System in 1976 with an offer to donate half of the property to the park system. When she died in 1977, she deeded half of the property for "park and horticultural purposes only". The remaining half of the property was purchased by the park system using funds from the
New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection's Green Acres Program. Between 2007 and 2010, the park system restored the original rose parterre in cooperation with
Rutgers University. Aerial photographs of the original garden were used to inform the restoration, which repaired the crumbling stone walls and replanted the rose beds. ==Gardens description==