Baltimore Ravens Olatoye was signed as an
undrafted free agent by the
Baltimore Ravens after the
2014 NFL draft on May 12.
Kansas City Chiefs On October 8,
2014, the
Kansas City Chiefs signed Olatoye to their
practice squad after
Phillip Gaines and
Chris Owens suffered injuries. He was cut from the practice squad on September 8.
Dallas Cowboys On September 9,
2015, Olatoye was signed to the
Dallas Cowboys' practice squad. After releasing
defensive back Corey White, the Cowboys promoted him to the active roster on November 18. His first start came in the fifteenth game of the season against the
Buffalo Bills in place of an injured
Morris Claiborne. He registered five
tackles, one pass defensed and an
interception. In
2016, Olatoye was used at
cornerback and
safety during
training camp. He was having a solid preseason until the last game against the
Houston Texans, when he struggled after being targeted by the opposing
quarterbacks. On September 3, he was released after being passed on the depth chart by
Dax Swanson.
Atlanta Falcons On September 5,
2016, the
Atlanta Falcons signed Olatoye to their practice squad. He was promoted to the active roster on November 23. Olatoye and the Falcons reached
Super Bowl LI, where they faced the
New England Patriots. In the final, he had two total tackles as the Falcons fell in a 34–28 overtime defeat. On September 21,
2017, Olatoye was waived by the Falcons.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers On October 25,
2017, Olatoye signed with the
Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He was waived by the Buccaneers on November 7. Olatoye was re-signed on November 29. He was waived again on December 12.
Atlanta Falcons (second stint) On December 14,
2017, Olatoye was signed by the
Atlanta Falcons to replace
cornerback C. J. Goodwin and provide depth. He was waived on December 29.
Orlando Apollos In
2019, Olatoye joined the
Orlando Apollos of the
Alliance of American Football. He was placed on the
injured reserve list before the start of the season and later was activated on March 5. The league ceased operations in April 2019.
Houston Roughnecks Olatoye was selected in the first round during phase four in the 2020 XFL Draft by the
Houston Roughnecks. In March, amid the
COVID-19 pandemic, the league announced that it would be cancelling the rest of the season. Playing in all five games, he registered four tackles and no interceptions. He had his contract terminated when the league suspended operations on April 10, 2020. ==Personal life==