He was drafted by the NBA's Minneapolis Lakers twice (in 1954 and again in 1955) and joined the team for the
1955–56 NBA season. As a result of that fact, Garmaker became the first player in NBA history to be selected in multiple
NBA drafts before the practice eventually became abolished in the 1980s. As a rookie in 1955-56, Garmaker, playing shooting guard, averaged 5.7 points, 1.9 rebounds and 1.5 assists in only 13 minutes per game. His teammates included Hall of Famers
Clyde Lovellette,
Slater Martin and
Vern Mikkelsen, as well as his Golden Gophers teammate, point guard Chuck Mencel. He was the backup shooting guard to his mentor Whitey Skoog. In his four-and-a-half seasons with the Lakers, Garmaker appeared as an
NBA All-Star four times, but the team never finished above .500. He arguably had his finest season in
1956–57, in which he ranked tenth in the league in points per game (16.3), earned a spot on the All-NBA second team, and was a starter on the Western Division All-Star team. He also averaged 4.7 rebounds and 2.6 assists, in 33.4 minutes per game (second to Lovellette on the team). Ironically, the increased playing time opened up for Garmaker when Skoog suffered a back injury that effectively ended his NBA career. Garmaker was an All-Star game starter again the following season (1957-58), while averaging 16.1 points, 5.4 rebounds and 2.7 assists per game. Garmaker made the All-Star team as a reserve in 1959 and 1960. In 1958-59, his last full season with the Lakers, he averaged 13.7 points, 4.5 rebounds and 2.9 assists per game during the regular season. Although under .500, the Lakers led by rookie
Elgin Baylor made the playoffs, reaching the NBA finals against
Bill Russell and the
Boston Celtics, where they lost in four games. Garmaker averaged 19.3 points and 4.3 rebounds per game against the Celtics. In January 1960, he was traded to the
New York Knicks for backup center
Ray Felix, cash and an exchange of draft picks. The Lakers were having a poor season, and had lost five straight games at the time of the trade. Garmaker had already been named an All-Star that season, and was averaging 27 minutes and 11.7 points per game, his fewest since his rookie season with the Lakers. In September 1960, before the 1960-61 season started, Garmaker announced his retirement so he could devote full time to his Minnesota based insurance business. The retirement was brief, and Garmaker rejoined the team in early November. During the 1960-61 season, the Knicks used Garmaker as a point guard alongside future Hall of Fame guard
Richie Guerin. He averaged 15.6 points (his highest since 1958), 3.1 assists and 3.9 rebounds in 31.5 minutes per game. In his six-year career, Garmaker scored 5,597 points, averaging 13.3 points, 4.3 rebounds and 2.6 assists in nearly 29 minutes per game. ==Death==