Washington Redskins The
Washington Redskins drafted Lynch in the sixth round of the
1958 NFL draft, 66th overall. As a rookie in 1958, Lynch started 10 games at right cornerback for Washington. He had two interceptions and a fumble recovery that season. He had a leaping one-handed interception against future Hall of Fame quarterback
Norm Van Brocklin and the
Philadelphia Eagles in the season's last game. As a rookie, he gained a reputation as a hard-hitting defensive back who was skilled in diagnosing plays.
New York Giants After the 1958 season, Lynch served six months as a
Reserve Officers' Training Corps lieutenant in the
signal corps at
Fort Monmouth,
New Jersey. was the team's defensive coach, under head coach
Jim Lee Howell. After seeing Lynch play for Washington, Landry was the person who wanted to bring Lynch to the Giants. Lynch had grown up a Giants' fan, and was extremely happy to be joining the team. The Giants finished the season with a 10–2 record, and reached the
1959 NFL Championship Game; losing to the
Baltimore Colts, 31–16. On offense, the Colts won behind future Hall of Fame quarterback
Johnny Unitas, his future Hall of Fame receivers
Lenny Moore and
Raymond Berry, and tight end
Jim Mutscheller. While the Giants had difficulty overall defensively, Lynch did a reasonably good job against Berry. In 1960, Lynch started all 12 Giants' games at right cornerback. He had three interceptions and two fumble recoveries that season. In the season's final game against the
Cleveland Browns, Lynch intercepted quarterback
Milt Plum's first pass of the game and returned it 16 yards for a touchdown. Lynch started all 14 games at right cornerback for the Giants in 1961. He led the NFL in interceptions, with nine. He also had one quarterback sack. He also had three interceptions in a mid-November game against the Philadelphia Eagles; including two on passes thrown by future Hall of Fame quarterback
Sonny Jurgensen. Lynch then had two interceptions the next week against the
Pittsburgh Steelers.
United Press International (UPI) named Lynch a second-team All-Pro in 1961. The Giants had a 10–3–1 record that season, and lost in the
1961 NFL Championship Game to the
Green Bay Packers, 37–0. In 1962, Lynch started 13 games at right cornerback, with five interceptions on the season. In a September 1962 game against the Philadelphia Eagles, he returned a blocked field goal for a touchdown. Giants' safety
Jimmy Patton had recovered the ball after the blocked field goal and run 12 yards. Patton then
lateralled the ball to Lynch who ran the remaining 65 yards for a touchdown; to loud boos from the
Philadelphia fans. Two weeks later against the St. Louis Cardinals, Giants' linebacker
Sam Huff blocked a punt into the endzone, which Lynch recovered for a touchdown. He also had an interception in the same game. The Giants were 12–2 that season, and lost in the
1962 NFL Championship Game to the Packers, 16–7. Lynch had his career best season in 1963. He once again led the NFL in interceptions with nine; tied with
Chicago Bears free safety
Roosevelt Taylor. He also led the league in interception return yards. Lynch returned three of those interceptions for touchdowns, tying for the league lead in non-offensive touchdowns with
Abe Woodson (who had three touchdowns on kick returns). Lynch had a 47-yard touchdown return on October 13 against the
Cleveland Browns, an 82-yard touchdown return on October 20 against the
Dallas Cowboys and his former defensive coach Tom Landry, and a 42-yard touchdown return on December 8 against the Washington Redskins (one of two interceptions he had in that game). Lynch had the second three-interception game of his career against the Philadelphia Eagles, in a late September game; with all three interceptions coming on Sonny Jurgensen passes. Lynch also had a quarterback sack that season. Lynch was selected to play in the
Pro Bowl for the first and only time at the end of the 1963 season. The Giants went to the
NFL championship game for the fourth time in Lynch's five years with the team, losing to the Chicago Bears, 14–10. Early in that game, Lynch and Huff hit Bears' quarterback
Bill Wade, causing him to fumble. Giants' cornerback
Erich Barnes recovered the ball, and the Giants went on to score their only touchdown of the game. In 1964, Lynch started 10 games at right cornerback, with four interceptions; but his play was hindered during the season by injury. Lynch returned to play all 14 games at right cornerback for the Giants in 1965. He had four interceptions and a career high four fumble recoveries. Lynch led the NFL that season in fumble return yards. He was named the AP's NFL Player of the Week for his performance in the Cardinals’ game. In his final season (1966), Lynch only appeared in eight games, starting three. He suffered a spinal injury in the first game of the season on September 11 against the Pittsburgh Steelers, and was placed on the injured list. He was not brought back to the Giants' active playing roster until October 20. Lynch announced his retirement in January 1967. In his Giants' career, Lynch played in 97 regular season games, starting 91, with 35 interceptions, 10 fumble recoveries and two quarterback sacks. He scored seven touchdowns on defense and special teams (four by interception returns, one by fumble recovery, one on a blocked punt, and one on a blocked field goal). Lynch played in four NFL championship games for the Giants, and twice led the NFL in interceptions. Overall in his career, he played in 109 games, started 101, with 37 interceptions and 11 fumble recoveries. == Legacy and honors ==