Critical response Teen Ink hailed Fairy Godmother as "the perfect villain", Hugh Hart of the
San Francisco Chronicle believed Saunders had won most of the film's "big laughs", while
JoBlo.com's Berge Garabedian described her as a "nice rendition" of the classic character. Dan DeMaggio of
Metro Times wrote that the character was "forever stealing the show", describing her as "a cross between a
Mary Kay cosmetics saleswoman and
Angela Lansbury in
The Manchurian Candidate".
Joe Morgenstern, film critic for
The Wall Street Journal, cited Fairy Godmother as an example of the film "match[ing] vivid vocal performances with engaging new characters".
Sympatico's Angela Baldassarre cited Fairy Godmother as an appealing character who "provide[s] the fodder needed to make this the must-see comedy of the season." Jon Niccum, writing for the
Lawrence Journal-World, reviewed that Fairy Godmother especially "adds flavor" to the film. Writing for
Slate, film critic
David Edelstein deemed Fairy Godmother a "remarkable creation, like the sugary/steely face of the modern Disney", while the
Deseret News' Jeff Vice observed that the character constantly steals the scene from Shrek and Fiona.
The Spinoff's Josie Adams considered Fairy Godmother "the only part of [the film] worth pissing yourself for." Writing for Game Rant, Victoria Rose Caister called the character a smart, fun villain who is "evil but also entertaining to watch and kind of likable."
The Washington Post's Michael O'Sullivan wrote that Saunders "brings a deliciously nasty edge to her role". Pete Vonder Haar of
Film Threat observed that Saunders "seems to enjoy giving voice to the Fairy Godmother", preferring her over Charming. Kevin Lally of
Film Journal International wrote that Saunders steals "the rest of the show ... bringing her
Absolutely Fabulous haughtiness and wicked wit to the role", while Rick Groen of
The Globe and Mail reviewed Fairy Godmother as some of Saunders' best work, hailing her character's entrance as "a gorgeous piece of animation". Also comparing Fairy Godmother to Saunders'
Absolutely Fabulous character
Edina Monsoon,
The Guardian journalist Decca Aitkenhead described her as "an ambitious
fag hag who bullies the royals as if they were her family in
Ab Fab", believing that her performance, humor and delivery can only be rivaled by
Eddie Murphy's Donkey.
The A.V. Clubs Tom Breihan said Saunders "has audible fun" in the role.
Christian website
Crosswalk.com deemed some of Fairy Godmother's behaviour "objectionable" and "unnecessary", particularly the scene in which she "writhes on a piano, singing a sexy song." Despite believing that Andrews could have voiced the character well, Bill Beyrer of
CinemaBlend felt that Saunders "did a bang up job", but found the character's appearance to be too realistic at times. In a more negative review, the
San Francisco Chronicle film critic
Mick LaSalle found the character too distracting from Shrek and Fiona's storyline, continuing, "The filmmakers invest too much time and faith in the idea of the fairy godmother as being wickedly amusing, but she's no
Cruella De Vil, and the movie suffers." However, LaSalle enjoyed Fairy Godmother's performance of "Holding Out for a Hero" nonetheless. While reviewing
Shrek Forever After (2010), Beth Patch of the
Christian Broadcasting Network expressed gratitude that Fairy Godmother was "no longer part of the cast", having been replaced by
Rumpelstiltskin as the film's villain.
Recognition Screen Rant ranked Fairy Godmother the third best
DreamWorks villain, with author Matthew Wilkson attributing her high placement to her deceptively kind nature. The author crowned her "one of the most memorable villains in the history of Dreamworks". one of five awards
Shrek 2 won at the ceremony. Allison J. Scharmann, contributing to the
Harvard Crimson, believed the "franchise would not be complete without the sequel’s introduction of Fairy Godmother".
The Daily Edge ranked Fairy Godmother the seventh reason "we need to appreciate Shrek more than we already do", with author Rachel O'Neill describing the character as "a STUNNING villain" who is "constantly fixing all the problems the men in her life cause her". Bailey Rymes of
Her Campus called Fairy Godmother the main reason she considers
Shrek 2 the second best film in the series, describing her as an icon.
Her Campus ranked Fairy Godmother the second "Top 10 Female Villains in Animation", with contributor Lilivette Domínguez writing, "instead of hating to love her, you love to hate her because she is a likable villain ... you can’t really hate her because she was smarter than everyone else".
Entertainment Weekly recognized Fairy Godmother as one of "13 who have us under their spell". At the
90th Academy Awards in 2018, several fans compared actress
Meryl Streep's red gown, up-do hairstyle and glasses to Fairy Godtmother's on social media. Fans also suggested that the actress play the character in a live-action adaptation of the film. == References ==