In 2004, WWE decided to make an extension of the Diva Search, including holding the contest live on
RAW and a one-year contract worth $250,000. Over 7,000 women applied to be a part of the search, }}The most controversial segment from the contest took part during the "Diss The Diva" challenge on the August, 30, episode of
RAW. Before the challenge began, Maria Kanellis was eliminated from the competition and gave Carmella DeCesare the
middle finger. The contest began with Giovanni calling out DeCesare stating; "''Carmella, you talk a lot of shit, but look at you, you've got a gap so wide you could drive a truck right through there baby!".'' Weber went on to also call out DeCesare calling her a "whore" and claiming she "didn't know shit, about wrestling", she then went on to tell DeCesare that having a
cock in her mouth had nothing to do with wrestling, before calling her a bitch. DeCesare responded by outing Giovanni as a mother, something she had not told WWE higher-ups, and calling her fat. She then went on to claim that Weber was jealous of her and that
Playboy laughed at Weber's attempt to audition for the magazine. Hemme continued the verbal beatdown on DeCesare by calling her a "
cum-burping gutter slut". The censors could not keep up with the live audio with
RAW commentators Jerry Lawler and Jim Ross asking if they were still on air. In a 2023 interview Giovanni revealed that she was confronted by
Stephanie McMahon backstage about having a child. The winner of the 2004 WWE Diva Search was Christy Hemme. Jamie Lynn, Maria Lemone, Mariza Villarreal, Radhaa Nilia and Tiffany Holliday.
Official themes The 2004 WWE Raw $250,000 Diva Search featured four official theme songs. • "
Open Your Eyes" by
Alter Bridge • "Real Good Girl" by
Jim Johnston • "Time and Time Again" by
Chronic Future • "
Walk Idiot Walk" by
The Hives Top 28 Open casting calls were held in Los Angeles, California, New York, New York, and Chicago, Illinois, in June and July of 2004. The following 28 finalists were chosen from each of the locations:
Finalists After the competition Christy Hemme went on to pose on the cover of
Playboy magazine and competed at
WrestleMania 21 for the WWE Women's Championship against
Trish Stratus in a losing effort. and found more success in
Total Nonstop Action Wrestling (TNA). She worked for TNA from 2006 until her retirement in 2016, briefly returning in a backstage role from 2022 until 2025, in 2006 she was fan-voted the TNA Knockout of the Year. Despite never signing a contract with the WWE, Carmella DeCesare went on to face Christy Hemme at
Taboo Tuesday 2004, in a losing effort, before leaving the wrestling business completely. Tracie Wright starred in the reality series
8th & Ocean. Joy Giovanni went on to become the valet of the
Big Show, being involved in the main event of Smackdown! She was fan-voted the WWE 2005 Rookie Diva of the Year, before being released in July 2005. She returned in 2009, for one night only, as a legend Diva in the
WrestleMania 25 battle royal. Amy Weber went on to become the valet of
John "Bradshaw" Layfield, being involved in the main event of Smackdown! She quit the company in February, 2005, due to alleged bullying and harassment from Edge and Randy Orton. Maria Kanellis went on to work for the WWE from 2004-10. During her time she posed on the cover of
Playboy magazine in 2008 and was fan-voted the 2009 WWE Diva of the Year. She went on to work across various other wrestling promotions including;
Ring of Honor (ROH),
New-Japan Pro Wrestling (NJPW) and TNA, where she became a one time
TNA Knockout's Champion. She returned to the WWE again in 2017, becoming a one time
WWE 24/7 Champion, before being released in 2020 due to budget cuts related to the
COVID-19 pandemic. She debuted and worked for
All Elite Wrestling (AEW) in 2022, departing in February, 2025. Michelle McCool went on to work for the WWE from 2004-11. During her time she went on to become a two time WWE Women's Champion and the inaugural
WWE Divas Champion, which she also won on two separate occasions. She won a battle royal to win the 2010 Slammy for WWE Diva of the Year, and won the 2010 Knucklehead Moment of the Year award that night. She most notably was one half of
LayCool, alongside future 2006 winner,
Layla El, during their time as a team they drew the highest television ratings on Smackdown! during their feud against
Mickie James and went on to face
The Divas of Doom (
Beth Phoenix and
Natalya) in the first ever women's tables match. In 2025, during an appearance on ESPN's
Get Up alongside her husband
The Undertaker,
Triple H appeared via satelite to surprise McCool with an induction into the
WWE Hall Of Fame Class of 2025, making her the third contestant and the first 2004 contestant to receive that honor. That year, she was the winning Legend in the second season of
WWE LFG. Despite being rejected from the competition, Candice Michelle went on to work for the WWE from 2004-09. During her time she posed on the cover of
Playboy magazine and won the WWE Women's Championship. She also won the WWE 24/7 Championship. In 2026, she signed to TNA as a backstage producer. ==2005==