Chicago Cardinals In the
1951 National Football League Draft, Joyce was picked 18th overall by the
Chicago Cardinals, in the second round. He started one game for the Cardinals in 1951, and 11 games for the Cardinals the following season at tackle. In the opening game of the 1952 season against the
Washington Redskins, the 6 ft 3 in (1.91 m) 250 lb (113.4 kg) 23-year old Joyce got into a fist fight with future Hall of Famer
Sammy Baugh, Washington's 38-year old quarterback and coach. This resulted in both being ejected from the game. As stated at the time, "It was the first time in the pro career of the usually calm Baugh – starting his 16th season with the Redskins – that he had been" ejected. In a November 30 game, Joyce
sacked Philadelphia Eagles quarterback
Bobby Thomason in the
end zone, and Joyce's teammate
Volney Peters recovered the ensuing fumble for a Cardinals' touchdown, in an upset victory for the Cardinals. In 1953, Joyce started eight of 10 games in which he appeared for the Cardinals. In a September 13 game against the
San Francisco 49ers, Joyce got into an altercation with 49ers center
Bill Johnson. Johnson accused Joyce, whom he considered a friend, of giving Johnson a knee to the stomach earlier in the game. Two plays after their altercation, Joyce was carried off the field.
Baltimore Colts The Cardinals traded Joyce to the
Baltimore Colts before the 1954 season for
Bill Lange. He started all 12 games that season at right defensive end for the Colts. In a December 5 game against the
Los Angeles Rams, Rams guard
Les Richter alleged that Joyce had pulled Richter's helmet off his head and then hit Richter in the face with the helmet. Richter needed 14 or 15 stitches over his right eye, and the incident was argued to be part of a trend across the NFL where "dirty tactics" were injuring the league's top players. Colts future Hall of Fame coach
Weeb Ewbank reportedly said after the game that Joyce's actions were "'uncalled for'" and he had told his players not to retaliate even if provoked. Joyce was ejected from the game. The following season
Life magazine used a photo of an agonized Richter lying on the ground as part of an article on savagery in football, implying it was the result of Joyce’s dirty tactics. The Rams demanded that NFL Commissioner
Bert Bell punish Joyce. Joyce, however, denied Richter's version of events, and the Colts President Don Kellett said movies of the play would vindicate Joyce (Kellett also claiming Joyce had been struck in the groin). Joyce said that during the first quarter play at issue, Richter had kneed Joyce in the thigh and elbowed Joyce in the face. Joyce said that even after the play ended Richter came to knee him again, so Joyce thrust out his left arm, palm open, to keep Richter at a distance. Joyce believed his palm hit Richter's face guard which then went into Richter's face. Commissioner Bell held the fine in abeyance until he could review movies of the game to try to get at what actually occurred. After reviewing the game movie, Bell determined that Joyce's version reflected what had occurred, and that he had been acting in self-defense. Bell rescinded the fine. The Rams had lost the game at issue, with their coach Hampton Pool observing that it was the play of the overwhelming Colts defense and their huge defensive line, including Joyce and future Hall of Famers defensive end
Gino Marchetti and
defensive tackle Art Donovan, among others, that defeated the Rams. It was one of only three wins for the Colts in 1954. In 1955, the Colts went 5–6–1, with Joyce starting 11 games at right defensive end. In addition to having Marchetti and Donovan, in 1955 the team added rookies
Alan Ameche (the 1954
Heisman Trophy winner) and future Hall of Fame receiver
Raymond Berry. In 1956, Joyce again started all 12 games at right defensive end. The team had a 5–7 record, but was joined by two future Hall of Fame players, quarterback
Johnny Unitas and
running back/
flanker Lenny Moore, and defensive tackle
Eugene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb, who would become a two-time All-Pro with the Colts (1958-59). The Colts defensive line now consisted of Joyce at right end, Lipscomb at right tackle, Donovan at left tackle and Marchetti at left end. In 1957, the Colts had their first winning season (7–5), and were joined by rookie
Jim Parker, a future Hall of Fame offensive tackle and guard. Joyce again started all 12 games at right defensive end. The team now included five players considered among the top 100 players in NFL history (Berry, Marchetti, Moore, Parker and Unitas). The 1957 Colts' defense led the NFL in holding opposing runners to 3.1 yards per carry. In
1958 and
1959 the Colts won the
NFL championship over the
New York Giants. During the 1958 championship game, often called “the Greatest Game Ever Played", Joyce recovered a
Frank Gifford fumble during the first half, after which the Colts moved 86 yards in 14 plays for a touchdown. Joyce started 11 games at right end in 1958 and was named to the
Pro Bowl following the
1958 season, to replace Marchetti who suffered a broken leg in the championship game; joining Pro Bowl teammates Lipscomb, Ameche, Berry, Moore, Parker and Unitas. In 1959, he started 10 games at right end. From 1957 to 1959, although Joyce started almost every game, he shared playing time at right defensive end with
Ordell Braase. In 1960, Braase became the starter at right defensive end, with Joyce playing as a reserve.
Minnesota Vikings and Denver Broncos The Colts left Joyce exposed in the 1961
expansion draft, and he was selected by the
Minnesota Vikings in their inaugural season. He started seven games for the Vikings in 1961. The Vikings released him before the start of the 1962 season. In 1962, Joyce played for the
American Football League's
Denver Broncos. This was Joyce's final season. He suffered a variety of injuries with the Broncos, and played only six games for the Broncos, starting in two, before the Broncos waived him in November. Berry also said because Joyce was so big and strong he could not be easily moved or blocked, so teams would have to maneuver around him on running plays. who was known in part for using the straight-arm clothesline technique across the necks of receivers, said Joyce was among the group of players during his time who played in that rough style. Brettschneider said "'You couldn't turn your back on Don Joyce'". Joyce boasted that he never lost an NFL fight. The
Green Bay media said Skoronski was retaliating after being hit by Joyce, but the referee only saw Skoronski's punch. Joyce also had a history of fights with New York Giants’ Hall of Fame offensive tackle
Roosevelt Brown. They got in two fights in the 1958 preseason, during an exhibition game in Baltimore in which Brown was said to have gotten the best of Joyce, but was ejected; and another in Louisville. They were speaking negatively of each other publicly up to the day before the 1958 championship game between the Colts and Giants. In his book on the 1958 championship game, New York Giant Hall of Fame running back
Frank Gifford writes that Joyce and Brown had a feud and history of fighting, and that Joyce once broke Brown's cheekbone during a game with a
lacrosse pad Joyce was wearing under his jersey. However, in a 1964 biographical piece on Brown based on information provided by Brown, the
New York Times detailed how Brown suffered the broken cheekbone against the Colts when he was crushed between Lipscomb and Marchetti, shattering Brown’s helmet and breaking his cheekbone; not as a result of any action by Joyce. Joyce also had a reputation as a tremendous eater, once easily defeating Marchetti in a fried chicken eating contest and earning a $500 pool of money put up by their teammates for the victor. == Scouting career ==