Contemporary reviews An upbeat Harrison song in the mould of "
What Is Life" and "
You", "Don't Let Me Wait Too Long" has regularly been singled out as one of the highlights of
Living in the Material World. In his album review for
Rolling Stone,
Stephen Holden called the track "a gorgeous, rollicking love song", while
Billboard magazine listed it second among the album's "best cuts", after the
title track. In
Melody Maker, Michael Watts wrote of the song's "Spector touches", including "a crashing two-beat on piano and a great surge of drums, straight from [the Ronettes'] '
Be My Baby'". While otherwise lamenting the overt religiosity of the album,
Tony Tyler of the
NME identified "Don't Let Me Wait Too Long" as the best track, describing it as "bright and hopeful" with a "memorable melody to commend it".
NME critic Bob Woffinden later remarked on the "exceptionally fine" music on
Material World, saying that "Don't Let Me Wait Too Long" "could rank with his best compositions". In his 1977 book
The Beatles Forever, Nicholas Schaffner wrote that Harrison and his former bandmates
John Lennon and
Paul McCartney had "evolved into surprisingly tasteful and meticulous producers" after their long association with Beatles producer
George Martin, and added of Harrison: "Surely Phil Spector never had a more attentive pupil."
Retrospective assessment Among commentators in the 21st century, authors Chip Madinger and Mark Easter describe "Don't Let Me Wait Too Long" as "a marvelous track" and "a prime piece of pop songwriting", John Metzger of
The Music Box writes of the track's "brightly colored radiance" being a "prime example" of how Harrison successfully mixed elements of Spector and Martin's individual styles on
Material World. While considering the album's production an improvement on
All Things Must Pass,
Blogcritics writer Chaz Lipp views the "soaring 'Don't Let Me Wait Too Long'" as a song that "rank[s] right alongside Harrison's best work".
Bruce Spizer describes it as "a great rocker", a "
hook-laden love song [that] moves at a brisk pace", and concludes: "Had Apple issued the track as planned, it surely would have been a hit." In his review of the
2006 remastered album, for
Mojo magazine,
Mat Snow said that "this long overdue reissue is worth it alone for four wonderful songs", of which "Don't Let Me Wait Too Long" "reveals the lusty lad within the orange robes" associated with Hare Krishna devotees. More recently, Snow has described
Material World as "a treat for the ears" and Harrison as "an old-school pop tunesmith to his marrow, [who] worked hard to ensure the choruses of 'Don't Let Me Wait Too Long,' '
The Day the World Gets 'Round,' and 'Who Can See It' caught the ear with their deep and delicious emotion". Reviewing the
2014 reissue of Harrison's Apple catalogue, for
Classic Rock, Paul Trynka writes that
Living in the Material Word "sparkles with many gems", and adds: "but it's the more restrained tracks – Don't Let Me Wait Too Long, Who Can See It – that entrance: gorgeous pop songs, all the more forceful for their restraint." Writing for
PopMatters, Scot Elingburg pairs the song with "
Be Here Now" as "would-be hits" from
Material World that "offer much more than just Harrison's Hindu-inspired teachings; they also offer up the chance for larger dialogue within music." Nick DeRiso, co-founder of the music website Something Else!, includes "Don't Let Me Wait Too Long" among the highlights of Harrison's solo career on Apple Records, and terms it "[a] masterpiece of coiled anticipation". Simon Leng refers to "Don't Let Me Wait Too Long" as "one of George Harrison's most perfect pop confections", while praising its guitar fills and musical arrangement. Describing it as a "single-that-never-was", Leng suggests that the song would have been a "certain number 1". To Huntley, "Don't Let Me Wait Too Long" is "a superlative slice of almost McCartney-esque pop", with Harrison's "exquisite slide guitar" a particular highlight. ==Other versions==