AllMusic editor Stephen Schnee described the song as a "delectable slice of '90s
disco".
J.D. Considine from
The Baltimore Sun felt that "there's not enough of the
single's goofy charm to sustain disco throwbacks" like "Don't Talk Just Kiss".
Billboard magazine found that singer
Richard Fairbrass "has a distinctive
baritone voice", adding that he "shines brightest" on the song.
Billboard editor
Larry Flick wrote, "Now that they've proven how "sexy" they are, Fred and friends want you to pucker up...immediately." He also complimented it as "an equally appealing
pop/house gem that benefits from a guest vocal from club dynamo
Jocelyn Brown" and an "infectious
hook". Clark and DeVaney from
Cash Box commented, "Who would have ever figured a couple of body builders would cause such a ruckus in the music business?". They added that "Don't Talk Just Kiss" "is actually more of a real song than its predecessor, but still manages to contain enough of a repetitious beat to keep this act in the clubs." Andy Kastanas from
The Charlotte Observer wrote, "Not only does it borrow its sound from disco of the '70s, but it borrows one of its personalities. Disco diva Jocelyn Brown lends her vocal chords to R.S.F. to make for a rollicking good
dance song." Alan Jones from
Music Week's
RM Dance Update declared it as "a Seventies-flavoured disco groove allowing Jocelyn plenty of opportunities to ad-lib, which she does in her usual paint-blistering manner." Johnny Dee from
Smash Hits named it "another cracker" and "a brilliant pop record – funny catchy, you can do daft dances to it. The lyrics are great too – "Don't talk just kiss/Let your tongue fool around"." ==Track listings==