Critics from
The Guardian have commented on the stark realism of Doreen's characterisation and stories. Gareth McLean opined that Doreen and Billy were a true reflection of "the aspiring lower-middle-class" living in Liverpool. Shyama Perera wrote that Doreen's debt problems were a common problem faced by many in society. In the book
British Television Drama in the 1980s, writers analysed an argument between Doreen and Sheila and compared it with an argument between the
Dynasty characters
Alexis Colby (
Joan Collins) and
Krystle Carrington (
Linda Evans). Their conclusion was that ''Brookside's'' portrayal of women was more realistic than those featured in American soap operas. Hilary Kingsley, writing for
Sunday Mirror believed that the Corkhills were a "semi-comic, semi-tragic" clan with believable characters. She added "don't you just know a nutter like Billy and a silly cow like Doreen?" Matt Wolf from
The Sacramento Bee stated that ''Brookside's'' characters, such as the Corkhills, represent the British working class and their problems. They added "a typical episode shows the Corkhills behind in their rent. Tracy's job is in the balance, Billy is unemployed and Doreen bets on horses to make ends meet." The Corkhills' house was depicted as the most rundown household on Brookside Close. Author Geoff Tibbals quipped "the natural starting point for any tour of the Close is the Corkhills' house, which, in the days of Doreen and Billy, was the only residence a brick through the window qualified as a home improvement." Lynne St Claire from the
Nottingham Post branded Doreen a "wily" character. In the book,
To Be Continued... Soap Operas Around the World, Christine Geraghty wrote that Doreen was an example of one of ''Brookside's
early authentic female characters. Geraghty branded Doreen a "strong mother" and assessed that she was someone "who controlled and negotiated family life within the home." She added that the show lacked such female roles during the 1990s. A Liverpool Echo'' writer branded Doreen a "wonderful woman" who put up with Billy's whining. They added, "I really think it's time she pushed the miserable little berk under a bus." ==References==