Censorship Douban has attracted a large number of intellectuals who are eager to discuss social issues. This makes Douban vulnerable to censorship by the Chinese government. Douban reviews all content posted on the website, preventing some material from being posted in the first place, and taking down other materials after the fact. This led to a campaign called "Portraits: Dress up" in which internet users were asked to dress up images of famous renaissance nudes in a protest against Douban's self-censorship. The administrators then removed the discussion about the campaign. This angered some members, causing them to move to other similar websites that employ less strict self-censorship policies.
Academy Awards In 2021 amid
controversy surrounding the 93rd Academy Awards over scrutiny of
Nomadland director
Chloé Zhao, Douban removed mentions of films' Academy Awards wins and nominations from its film pages. However, comments about the Academy Awards by Douban users remained on the site.
The Wandering Earth ratings Douban has been accused that many users of Douban purposely gave
The Wandering Earth, a 2019 Chinese science-fiction film, one star. Critics further accused that some users "change their given five stars to one star" and some users are paid to give one star to the film, which later turned out to be false. On 12 February 2019, Douban officially announced that "mass score-changing is abnormal and it won't be counted in the total score. To avoid such incidents, we are urgently optimizing product features." in its official
Sina Weibo account.
New releases On December 27, 2016, People's Daily's mobile app republished an article from China Film News, retitling it as "Ratings on Douban and
Maoyan Face Credibility Crisis; Negative Reviews Harm the Film Industry." The article reported that the low ratings on Douban and
Maoyan for three major holiday-season releases —
Railroad Tigers, See You Tomorrow, and
The Great Wall—left many moviegoers disappointed in Chinese New Year domestic films, and even deterred some from watching them. Some netizens worried that the authorities might tighten control over Douban and other online communities in order to protect domestic films. They voiced objections online, refuting accusations in the article that malicious "review brigades" were manipulating ratings. However, on December 28,
People's Daily's commentary section published an article titled "Chinese Cinema Must Have the Tolerance for One-Star Reviews." The commentary argued that acknowledging moviegoers' right to "vote with their feet" also means acknowledging their right to give star ratings; both are forms of choice. The piece distanced itself from the earlier criticism of negative reviews.
Rating Researchers have found correlations between Douban ratings and domestic box-office performance, making manipulation allegations particularly notable for stakeholders. In February 2011, a
Sina Weibo user named "Xue Mang" revealed that a year earlier, he had fabricated a non-existent "film" titled
Even If Kafka Turned Into a Beetle, ''He Still Couldn't Enter the Castle
and created a related page on Douban. All of the "film content" was based on his personal experiences. A year later, this completely fictional "film" received an impressively high rating of 8.9 on Douban—on par with The Lord of the Rings
and Let the Bullets Fly,
and even surpassing Avatar
and Titanic''. Among the 235 users who rated it, as many as 88.8% gave it a full five stars. Additionally, 2,457 people marked that they "wanted to watch" the film, and some users even wrote detailed reviews discussing the plot specifics of this entirely fabricated work. After "Xue Mang" disclosed the truth about the hoax, Douban removed the page for the so-called "film". However, on February 20, 2011, "Xue Mang" also stated on Weibo that many of the reviews were intentionally added by netizens after his post in order to "make the situation more fun." In 2016, due to media misunderstandings, he again clarified on Douban that the incident was "a long-running joke," and affirmed that "Douban is the most authoritative and credible film-rating platform in China". == Platform comparisons ==