Pittsburgh Steelers Whaley worked for the Steelers as a pro personnel coordinator. He worked there for 10 years before accepting the Buffalo Bills job. Whaley worked directly under
Kevin Colbert the Director of Football Operations. In his time with the Steelers, Whaley helped scout and draft defensive players such as
Lamarr Woodley,
Troy Polamalu and
Lawrence Timmons.
Buffalo Bills Whaley was named assistant general manager and Director of Pro Personnel of the Buffalo Bills on February 10, 2010. Whaley oversaw the team's Pro Personnel department and assisted General Manager
Buddy Nix in all football-related administrative duties and in the college talent evaluation process until Nix stepped down from the general manager position on May 13, 2013. Whaley became Buffalo's GM three days later. His most notable moves with Buffalo included trading up to draft receiver
Sammy Watkins and trading linebacker
Kiko Alonso for All-Pro running back
LeSean McCoy. The move to draft Watkins has been questioned, as wide receivers
Mike Evans,
Odell Beckham Jr., and
Brandin Cooks were picked later in the first round. Whaley was, in conjunction with owners
Terry and
Kim Pegula and President
Russ Brandon, responsible for the hiring of head coach
Rex Ryan. After Ryan was relieved of his duties, the team announced that Whaley would lead the search for Ryan's successor,
Sean McDermott. On January 10, 2016, Whaley agreed to a contract extension offered to him by the Bills. Whaley, alongside his staff, was "relieved of his duties" by the Bills on April 30, 2017, following the
2017 NFL draft. He spent the 2018 season as a recruiter for the
NFLPA Collegiate Bowl.
XFL and UFL On November 8, 2018, Whaley was hired as the senior vice president of football operations for the
revival of the XFL. On April 10, 2020, Whaley was laid off, along with almost every staff member after the league suspended operations due to COVID-19. On November 8, 2021, Whaley was re-hired as the vice president of player personnel of the
XFL He retained his office as the XFL merged into the United Football League. In December 2025, with the UFL reorganizing into a centralized front office that eliminates team general managers, Whaley was assigned general manager duties for the entire league. ==Controversies==