2023 Caylor made her senior debut at the
2023 Winter Cup, where she placed seventh on uneven bars. In August, she competed at the
2023 U.S. Classic and placed twelfth on floor and sixteenth on uneven bars and balance beam. She then competed at the
2023 National Championships, where she placed sixteenth on floor and 21st on uneven bars and balance beam.
2024 In February, Caylor competed at the
2024 Winter Cup and placed fifth in the all-around, seventh on uneven bars and eighth on balance beam. Following the Winter Cup, she was then selected to compete at the
DTB Pokal Mixed Cup in
Stuttgart, alongside
Fuzzy Benas,
Riley Loos, Kai Uemura,
Addison Fatta, and
Nola Matthews. There, she made her senior international debut and helped team USA finish first as a team. In April, she competed at the
2024 City of Jesolo Trophy and helped team USA finish third as a team behind Italy and Brazil. In May, she competed at the
Core Hydration Classic, where she finished eighth in the all-around. She then competed at the
National Championships and placed fourteenth in the all-around. As a result, she qualified for the
2024 Olympic Trials. At the Olympic trials, Caylor finished thirteenth in the all-around. After she failed to make the U.S. Olympic team, her parents gifted her tickets to the
2024 Summer Olympics. In October, she committed to the
Florida Gators.
2025 In April she competed at the
2025 City of Jesolo Trophy, where she helped team USA win silver in the team event, and placed sixth in the all-around and on floor. In May, she was selected to compete at the
2025 Pan American Championships alongside
Hezly Rivera,
Jayla Hang,
Gabrielle Hardie,
Tiana Sumanasekera, and alternate
Alessia Rosa. At the Championships, she helped the United States win gold as a team. At the
2025 National Championships, Caylor placed eighth in the all-around and won bronze on balance beam; as a result, she was added to the national team and invited to partake in the World Championships selection camp. In late September, Caylor participated in the selection camp for the
2025 World Championships. She won the all-around, which earned her an automatic spot on the team. The following day she was joined by
Skye Blakely,
Joscelyn Roberson, and
Leanne Wong. At the World Championships, she qualified in fifth place for the all-around final with a score of 52.765. She also qualified in sixth place for balance beam, and eighth place on floor exercise finals. She also had the highest single vault score (14.066) among athletes not contending for the apparatus final. During the all-around final Caylor placed thirteenth after falling on both the uneven bars and balance beam. She also placed sixth on floor with a score of 12.966 and eighth on balance beam with a score of 11.800. On November 12, 2025, she signed with Florida. On November 25, 2025, she announced she was deferring her enrollment at the University of Florida to pursue representing Team USA at the
2028 Summer Olympics in
Los Angeles. ==Competitive history==