Thomas Bracken, who at the had unsuccessfully contested the electorate, was the first representative. At the , Bracken was defeated by
James Benn Bradshaw, but Bradshaw died during the term (on 1 September 1886) and Bracken won the resulting by-election. He served for the rest of the term and then retired. The was contested by
Edward Cargill and
Frederick Fitchett, and won by Fitchett. Fitchett served one term and then retired. The electorate was abolished at the end of the term in 1890. When the electorate was recreated for the , the election was won by
John A. Millar of the
Liberal Party, who had represented various Dunedin electorates since . At the next election in , Millar successfully stood in the
Dunedin West electorate. The Dunedin Central electorate was won by
James Arnold in that year, who was also of the Liberal Party. At the , Arnold was beaten by
Charles Statham. Statham was a representative of the
Reform Party, but became an
Independent in 1919. Statham resigned after the , after irregularities in the counting of the vote turned a 12-vote lead for his competitor
Jim Munro into a 12-vote loss. Munro, who represented the
United Labour Party, and Statham contested the resulting , which was narrowly won by Statham. He continued to represent the electorate until his retirement in 1935.
Peter Neilson of the
Labour Party won the . He served for three terms before he retired in 1946. He was succeeded by Labour's
Phil Connolly in the , who served six terms before he retired.
Brian MacDonell of the Labour Party won the and served seven terms until 1984, when the electorate was abolished. MacDonell then failed to get selected by Labour for the
Dunedin West electorate and then stood as an Independent, but he was unsuccessful.
Members of Parliament The electorate was represented by nine
Members of Parliament:
Key ==Election results==