Much like other Assyrian militias that were formed after ISIS, Dwekh Nawsha was criticized for its alignment with the Kurdish Regional Government and for essentially acting as a Kurdish proxy. A report that was released by the
Assyrian Policy Institute in June 2020 stated that the founding of Dwekh Nawsha, as well as the
Nineveh Plain Forces and the Nineveh Plain Guard Forces (NPGF) of the
Chaldean Syriac Assyrian Popular Council was merely to serve as partly a public relations ploy, as well as a political maneuver to instill Kurdish influence in the Nineveh Plains. The API also criticized the significant gap in combat operations that the militia participated in compared to the public media discussion of the group. In August 2016, the president of the APP,
Emanuel Khoshaba Youkhana, appeared on
The Rubin Report and was introduced as the "Commander in Chief of the Assyrian Army", which was described as creating the illusion of Assyrian support for the militia. The group is also stated to have not taken part in the
Battle of Mosul, instead offering assistance or acting as a police unit for Assyrian villages in the
Nineveh Plains. Other criticisms were levied towards the militia, following on the premise of being a symbolic gesture with no actual participation in combat. In the Time Magazine article, a foreign soldier described how most of the time spent with the militia was spent sitting at their headquarters in
Nohadra, with soldiers not being allowed to hold weapons on the front lines. Samir Oraha, a member of the militia, stated in an interview that any actions of the militia would need explicit approval from the Peshmerga, and before the
Battle of Mosul, fighters were told to stand down. Later interviews with former members of the militia as part of a 2021 article revealed that the actual number of soldiers was significantly lower than reported, totaling anywhere from 15 to 50 with 10–15 on the frontline at any given point, and most of the members had little to no coordination or combat experience. Foreign volunteers typically shifted in and out of the militia, with many disappointed at the lack of combat experience, and that confidence quickly dropped in DN as time went on. While it's believed that Dwekh Nawsha still had some stronghold around
Tel Keppe and
Tesqopa in 2018, the same API report claimed that they were eventually disbanded and that all of their social media accounts had been deleted. == Legacy ==