Although it was an unfinished demo, "Earth Angel" began to see immediate success. Williams carried a rough acetate dub with him to
Dolphin's of Hollywood All Night Record Shop, a local record store, to gauge shop owner
John Dolphin's opinion. It made its first appearance in
Billboard as a territorial hit for Los Angeles, becoming the second best-selling R&B single in Los Angeles for the second week of October 1954. It climbed to number one for the city by November 13, after which it began to grow in popularity in New York, Philadelphia, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Buffalo, Pittsburgh, and Nashville. "Earth Angel" became the first independent label release to appear on
Billboard national pop charts. It hit number one in New York on November 27, and by Christmas Day the song was placing on the "Best Sellers in Stores" chart for both R&B and pop, where it debuted at number 25. By January 15, 1955, the single had advanced to the top 20 of the overall Best Sellers in Stores chart, resulting in its addition to the "Honor Roll of Hits" chart. It also reached number one on the "Most Played in Jukeboxes" R&B chart. After seven weeks on the chart, it peaked at number eight on the overall Best Sellers in Stores chart, and by February 19 had hit number one on all the major R&B charts. It remained a number one R&B hit for three weeks, before being dethroned by
Johnny Ace's "
Pledging My Love". When the Penguins switched to Mercury Records, the label reissued "Earth Angel" in September 1956 with string accompaniment. By 1963, Williams had told
Billboard the single had passed the 2,000,000 mark, and it was reported to be the top-selling single of Dootone Records (at this period renamed Dooto). The same year, it was reported that thousands of bogus copies of "Earth Angel" were attempted to be sold by an unidentified counterfeiter. The song has continued to sell multiple decades after its release; ==Legal issues==