Upon his release in 1786, Allan briefly moved to a site on
Oatka Creek 600 yards west of its mouth with the
Genesee River. The 475 acre plot had been gifted to him by landowners
Phelps and Gorham in gratitude for his services in the peace treaty. With his residence at the site, Allan became the first white settler of what would become Rochester, New York. The established site went through a few owners before being purchased by a group led by future city namesake and founder
Nathaniel Rochester. Allan moved further west in 1794, settling on land near modern
Windsor, Ontario. Allan got in trouble with government officials for his failure to build a promised church. Around 1805 he was imprisoned for an unknown offense in
Turkey Point, Ontario. Allan became an American sympathizer active in
Ontario during the
War of 1812. After brief imprisonment at
Niagara-on-the-Lake, Allan died in Delaware Township on April 13, 1813. == Personal life ==