Following
a schism at the
First Church and Parish in Dedham, and the accompanying lawsuit,
Baker v. Fales, Burgess was ordained pastor of the
Allin Congregational Church on March 14, 1821. In the run up to the Civil War, "he did not support the anti-slavery movement" and segregated the pews in the church by race. When a visiting southern clergyman was traveling through the area, Burgess would often invite him to preach. Congregants were sometimes offended by what the visiting preacher had to say. However, when President
Joseph Jenkins Roberts of
Liberia would visit the United States, he would frequently preach from the Allin pulpit. William Jenks, a pastor from Green Street in Boston, would spend the summers in Dedham. Burgess would invite him to stand on his left during services and Jenks would lead the "long prayer." He was a firm believer in the evangelical system of faith. His preaching was distinguished for breadth and comprehensiveness, rather than for pointedness and closeness of application. Burgess was "strict in his denominationalism" and did not associate with the other ministers in the town. Unlike many of the others, he did not serve on the
Dedham School Committee. If a congregant died, but owned a pew in another church, Burgess would not share in the funeral duties. When John Wade was sentenced to death for arson at the
Phoenix Hotel, Burgess intervened on his behalf and helped get it commuted to life imprisonment. Burgess resigned active pastoral duties on March 13, 1861. ==Published works==